Re:I'll sue you if you use my common-sense JavaScript tests
by Sensible on Wednesday December 16, 2009 @03:15PM
(#999624)
You can easily dismiss the numerous non-style related errors that JSLint finds because of the claim that JSLint "opinionated". And you can dismiss the numerous non-style related errors that one finds because you can claim a flaw in poster's personality.
The point being that I'm tired of reading responses that only focus on an insulting comment a poster makes in order to dismiss all valid technical criticism.
Re:I'll sue you if you use my common-sense JavaScript tests
by boucher on Wednesday December 16, 2009 @05:09PM
(#999865)
Then why not stop including insults with your technical criticisms?
If you include insults, purely stylistic criticism, and valid technical criticism all in an orgy of excited and angry words, people aren't going to take the time to dissect the actually interesting bits.
And, let's not forget, you're the one who claimed that jQuery and Prototype fail horribly on JSLint without providing any information on the actual errors, so the burden to prove they are not just style errors is still on you.
It's absolutely fine to have an automated tool to enforce style guidelines. But code which disagrees with that tool isn't necessarily bad. We have published style guidelines for our project, and they differ from Doug's. Those projects may very well have their own published guidelines.
Doug has never said that code which fails JSLint is obviously retarded, or written by fools. He's never publicly insulted individuals because he didn't agree with their design decisions, or written mailing list posts saying someone has "never written a competent script in his life."
So, what's your point?