Re:It’s time for the Uber of air travel
by tzs on Sunday August 02, 2015 @03:33PM
(#9992069)
> In the US passengers can be sued for damages when being involved in car accidents and cannot sue the driver unless they are paying passengers (which UBER doesn't qualify since it is not a licensed transport service)
The second part of that is only relevant in Alabama. The other 27 states that have or once had automobile guest statutes that prohibited passengers from suing their driver over negligence had, by 1996, either repealed them or limited them to cases where the passenger and driver were relatives.
I'm also not convinced that the risk of passengers being sued in an Uber-type situation is more than negligible. From what I've been able to find, passenger liability usually only happens in these circumstances:
• The passenger did something like provide alcoholic drinks to the driver before the trip, and then the driver's intoxication caused the accident.
• The passenger owns the car, and knew that the driver was incapable of operating safely, but went ahead and let him drive anyway.
• The passenger did something that reasonably directly led to the driver's negligence. A couple examples. (1) passenger tells the driver it is safe to back out of a driveway, and the driver relies on this rather than checking himself, and the passenger was wrong [1]. (2) 16-year old, at urging of similar aged friends, takes family's car for a ride in rainy weather. At urging of friends, drives faster and faster. Loses control at 100 mph and hits a tree. Driver and two passengers wearing seat belts survive, one passenger not wearing seat belt killed. Surviving passengers liable with driver for their role in in convincing driver to drive like an idiot.
I haven't come across an example where merely being a passenger in a car where the driver does something negligent subjected the passenger to liability.
[1] That's a scary one. I would expect most people as passengers have tried to help out a driver that way at sometime, often at the driver's request, without realizing that they may be opening themselves up to liability if they err.
The second part of that is only relevant in Alabama. The other 27 states that have or once had automobile guest statutes that prohibited passengers from suing their driver over negligence had, by 1996, either repealed them or limited them to cases where the passenger and driver were relatives.
Here's a good overview: http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Guest+Statutes
For a nice look at the history of these laws, up to 1974, here's a nice Columbia Law Review article from 1974: http://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?artic...
I'm also not convinced that the risk of passengers being sued in an Uber-type situation is more than negligible. From what I've been able to find, passenger liability usually only happens in these circumstances:
• The passenger did something like provide alcoholic drinks to the driver before the trip, and then the driver's intoxication caused the accident.
• The passenger owns the car, and knew that the driver was incapable of operating safely, but went ahead and let him drive anyway.
• The passenger did something that reasonably directly led to the driver's negligence. A couple examples. (1) passenger tells the driver it is safe to back out of a driveway, and the driver relies on this rather than checking himself, and the passenger was wrong [1]. (2) 16-year old, at urging of similar aged friends, takes family's car for a ride in rainy weather. At urging of friends, drives faster and faster. Loses control at 100 mph and hits a tree. Driver and two passengers wearing seat belts survive, one passenger not wearing seat belt killed. Surviving passengers liable with driver for their role in in convincing driver to drive like an idiot.
I haven't come across an example where merely being a passenger in a car where the driver does something negligent subjected the passenger to liability.
[1] That's a scary one. I would expect most people as passengers have tried to help out a driver that way at sometime, often at the driver's request, without realizing that they may be opening themselves up to liability if they err.