http://www.popularmechanics.com/military/a16248/test-pilot-f...
Rather than denying it, Lockheed's response was that it was intended for "long range" dominance. Axe's claim was that it would fire off its payload and be destroyed in dogfights by any planes that survived. The pilot's remarks and Lockheed's support that this is true... even if they have their older planes. ;)
Far as long-range, there's concerns even if we take Lockheed's word their stealth is great. Their word hasn't been reliable so far but let's pretend it is. That leaves two problems: engine being picked up by upgraded infrared sensors on next-gen aircraft; fact that tests showing long-range dominance were done with weapons it doesn't even have and still aren't in the program. Both mean it might not perform as well as expected with one being straight-up deceptive.
So, the evidence in dogfights, Lockheed's response, and their cooked tests show this plane is worthless. Upgrading proven designs that are each great at their respective missions would've been a better investment. Far as aircraft engineering, I haven't met one engineer that in private will endorse F-35 or existing VTOL aircraft. They all mock both while praising their choice of prior aircraft.
F-15's, A-10's, and F-18 Super Hornets get my vote for upgrade dollars. That's air, ground, and multi-mission. Maybe try to make the F-22 cheaper while they're at it. Improve some drones or human, recon craft. Throw in improvements on an ECM craft. All adds up for most bang for buck. Collective capability would rival a bunch of F-35's. Military with with the F-35's. Should've chosen Option A.
They're doing some cool stuff though, the military. The new railguns and laser systems the Navys building are pretty neat and will probably end up having some civilian benefits in the future.
This unfortunately feels like a huge sinkhole which won't produce any tangible benefit for the military or civilians.
One article pointed out that the F-22 acquisitions were canceled due to cost. Yet, they did seem to be untouchable in the air. Now, we have an enormously expensive plane that can't beat F-16's in short-range and might loose to China's clones in long-range. Prior gen performance approaches F-22 prices. (slow clap for U.S. military)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_access_program
I know in the 90's that Aviation Week reported that they spend around $100 million a day on these with a House committee admitted they review only 5-10% of them. So, plenty of money slushing around to who knows what. Every now and then we get details such as NSA's exploit development and subversion program costing around $212 million a year.
http://www.dss.mil/documents/odaa/nispom2006-5220.pdf
It's not the end all but it was a nice start to organizational security. Just had to... de-bureaucratize it into something a person could comprehend lol. Then worked from there based on expert writings in each subfield, spy vs spy literature, and what worked for organized crime dodging LEO's. And that's how one learns real security. :)
However, the aerospace industry and government have not stood still. Newer missiles are orders of magnitude more reliable and capable. High off boresight missiles mean that pilots can engage targets from a wide variety of angles. Seeker technology is amazingly better.
1) The exact nature of the specific F-35 used in that test, and how it differs from production aircraft in crucial ways
2) The intent of the test plan this test was conducted under. Axe says "The two jets would be playing the roles of opposing fighters in a pretend air battle, which the Air Force organized specifically to test out the F-35’s prowess as a close-range dogfighter in an air-to-air tangle". This basic assertion is incorrect. The intent was to test how the F-35's control laws responded to the kinds of inputs that it would receive in combat maneuvering, and how the pilot would feel about how the aircraft responded. As the pilot himself reports, "The test was designed to stress the high AoA [Angle of Attack] control laws during operationally representative maneuvers utilizing elevated AoAs and aggressive stick/pedal inputs".
3) The meaning of much of the language used in the pilot's feedback.
The key takeaway from the report was not, as Axe says, that the F-35 " is demonstrably inferior in a dogfight with the F-16", but, as the pilot himself says in the leaked report (I will not link to it -- it is ITAR controlled and should not have been distributed in the first place, but Axe has posted it), "Whereas rudder inputs often feel sluggisth or gradual/delayed, the anti-spin logic is immediate, abrupt, and forceful. Perhaps some of the available authority may be given to the pilot while still preventing departure." In other words -- the plane has more maneuverability in it, please give that to me. The pilot also recommends some changes to the seat to allow for better visibility, and a change to how various regions of the control laws are blended together.
By "Lockheed's response", did you mean https://www.f35.com/news/detail/joint-program-office-respons.... ? Because that's not Lockheed, that's the JSF Program Office -- run by the government. Their response was more nuanced and detailed than what you describe.
The pilot's remarks do not mean what you are asserting that they mean, as I have outlined above.
F-15's have already been upgraded significantly. A-10s have received two different service life extensions. F-18 legacy Hornets are receiving entirely new center barrels. All of this helps, but it's not a long term solution.
Making the F-22 cheaper sailed out the window when the current administration stopped production orders in 2009.
Edit: also, "Cooked tests"? The test plans are approved by the government and are conducted with government engineers participating in every single step of the process, from test design, simulation, planning, briefing, execution, and data analysis. Nothing is passed through as OK until the JSF Program Office approves of it. Please refrain from baseless speculation on a process that you have not participated in or witnessed.
You say that the F-35 engine would be picked up by upgraded sensors on next-gen planes ? But next-gen planes don't exist yet. So that means the F-35 would dominate older generation planes when in its preferred position. Which makes it anything but worthless does it not ?
https://medium.com/war-is-boring/no-the-f-35-can-t-fight-at-...
Contrary to your post, the goal of F-35 isn't to defeat outdated tech: must defeat old and next-gen tech. Performance at long-range looks like it was optimized to defeat old tech with a bit of improvement. The enemy's new tech is very improved and China straight up stole F-35 tech for theirs. With that, we must assume theirs is at least as good as F-35. Maybe more given that they eliminated its weaknesses in their version. Add Russia and the new radars to get anything but assurance that F-35 will deliver.
It might. So far it's failed on everything else, though, while specifically eliminating strengths in its design for politics essentially. Enemies's designs aren't doing that. So, I'm not betting on F-35 in any scenario.
One of my biggest gripes with the program right there. F-35 seems setup to fail against 5gen's while others aren't doing that in design decisions. I'll take everyone's word for it that the others' designs aren't finalized or sufficiently detailed to tell what they can do overall.
Its ironic that "everyone" claims the F-35 can't dogfight etc. forgetting that the former JSF program director [0] has actual experience in an actual dogfight[1].
[0] http://www.navy.mil/navydata/bios/navybio.asp?bioID=288
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf_of_Sidra_incident_(1981)
Helicopters, even a similarly over-armored model like the Russian Hind, don't have that kind of durability. Maybe we'll have close-air support drones eventually, but I would imagine a drone that has the flight characteristics to be a good gun-platform for strafing is still going to be vulnerable - this is flying in at altitudes where aimed small-arms fire can do damage.
The growing threat against western militaries are asymmetric threats, and the US's modus operandi for quite a while has been to empower the carrier strike groups to project power over wherever these threats may start heating up. If a carrier has to carry a bomber and two escorts and now an F35 can be 80% as good as each of those at their respective task but take up < 33% of the space, that seems valuable.
How does this whole F35 thing pan out when logistics like that are taken into account?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002
U.S. strategy and gear were totally defeated by an asymmetric response. Seems our tricks only win against 3rd world countries we hit. Add any brains, like we saw in Vietnam insurgency, to get a different scenario. That they then rigged it to make our failed strategy look good says even worse about our military leadership and outlook if we go against strong opposition in the future.
>that thing has been debunked so often... motorcycle couriers operating at lightspeed
got a link?
the original papers are to be found in mil resources.
Pretty poorly given the long mission turnaround time and otherwise low projected availability/readiness.
China's F-35 is already better than ours for instance. I'm not sure if they sent Lockheed a thanks for all the free R&D. ;)
Where is the evidence for this ?
Everything I've read about the J-31 has said that it isn't a match for the F-35 at all and actually isn't even a program yet (just a prototype has been built).
Please please stop taking "maybes" and speculation and presenting it as fact. That's what irks me about David Axe. I'm really confused, because I have read through some of your other commentary here on programming and security issues and you seem quite intelligent and solid there. So why spread so much FUD about something that's outside of your wheelhouse? You're certainly allowed and encouraged to ask questions, investigate, etc, but you're presenting yourself as an expert on this sort of thing when you aren't.
You have a point, though, in that my own bias against the wasteful program caused me to leverage sources without enough verification. I need to be more careful about that in near future. Thanks for calling me on it.
Least my stuff's still there to benefit whoever.
Any aircraft the Chinese make will presumably be put to some examination, some day. Will they be able to pass? Your guess is as good as anyone's.
Put that to good use after a visiting some true innovators at Xerox Palo Alto. ;)
Far as espionage, I lack the source on hand but one said what they got in a year from U.S. companies paid for their whole intelligence program in what they got on it.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nUXmqpRhTjQ
And against ISIL targets:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tn8R8ne9Pd0
That it can take tons of gunfire, counter missiles, rapidly disable targets (bombs/missiles), and selectively/cheaply do it (bullets) makes it ideal for current battles. Gotta imagine what beast would've come out of $1-5bil in improvements to that.
Remember, though, that these programs exist to put money back into Congressional districts more than anything else. That's why they do nothing about Pentagon being a financial sinkhole with broken accounting. So, they have to do upgrades, need a lot of money to move, and everyone wants a piece of it. Option A: invest small amounts to upgrade a few proven planes with their contractors and subcontractors; Option B: invest as much as a war into an unproven one with cash across many districts and capabilities a compromise across various branches. Option A is best for taxpayer but Option B is best those paid with taxes. Washington and Pentagon 101. ;)
https://medium.com/war-is-boring/fd-how-the-u-s-and-its-alli...
I was extra mad that they're moving to get rid of the A-10's in favor of this garbage. Originally learned about them with the A-10 Tank Killer games on PC. Later read how they shredded the opponents' vehicles in one campaign after another, even recent ones, despite being highly exposed to enemy fire. They're beasts. And that's just one example of something that does its job more effectively and at better cost than F-35... which is also being decommissioned to support F-35 program. There's quite a few more that each could've been updated with less money than F-35 took.