So, the fact that there are raving hordes of neo-religious freaks claiming that climate change science is bunk does not mean that those supporting the assertion that we are doing irreparable harm to our planet are absolved of all responsibility to actually prove that.
But why upvote this comment so much? It doesn't make any sense.
The "person presenting the argument" are the scientists that have published hundreds of peer reviewed papers on global warming science. Apparently they're not doing a good enough job of convincing some people, but they're not trying to get people to blindly agree with them, their doing science! What more are they supposed to do to prove it?
Environmental Science has become (and perhaps always has been) politicized. It's not the pure world like relativity, or quantum/particle physics, where there is a passionate desire (and even support, and funding) to find something that might contradict established beliefs/theories.
I suspect there is actually a hierarchy of science beliefs that looks like:
Political Environmental Science
Less Political Evolutionary Science
Apolitical Particle Physics
(Apologies to the 2% of HN that questions genomes/fossil records. :-)Used to be you could trust scientists to be pure - alas no more.
Who is really being political here?
Luckily, science will not stop because you say it should.
But, with that said, I am much more skeptical about environmental science than I would be about topics that are somewhat less politicized, such as Eötvös torsion balance experiments - and even _they_ turned out to have suspect results in hindsight.
And it wasn't the email regarding the "hiding" of data I was referring to - it was the several _hundred_ where the various scientists discussed how to discredit or otherwise shut down those who stood in opposition to the popular environmental theories.
I'm all for setting up the experiment and letting the results speak for themselves.
Marketing is the practical application of the science of sociology.
Also, the nice thing about the peer-reviewed literature is that it is published. Anybody can read it and point out inherent flaws. Indeed, if you can identify a serious problem in a paper, and back your discovery with facts, you'll have no problem getting your counter-point published. There are literally tens of thousands of examples of precisely this happening available for your perusal, in the peer-reviewed literature!
It's not like major polluters, such as oil companies, don't have the bankroll to fund scientists to demonstrate that the claims about climate change are false. Their continued silence is like the dog that didn't bark in Conan-Doyle's "Silver Blaze"
I am unable to judge the impact of that kind of obstruction on their actual scientific argument. It could well be that the significance of the so called climategate is way overblown.
But it's definately not confidence inspiring behaviour by scientists who have so much to gain from a global warming panic.
As for preventing critical review, I am unaware of any such activity. Do you have a citation?
One thing I consider preventing critical review is the lies about the original temperature readings that were thrown away in the 80s. The only plausible reason for lying about that is to make it easier for them to defend their own conclusions and make it more difficult for critics to check for errors.
But as I said many times before, I'm not one of those who claim to have found some kind of unambiguous smoking gun in those emails or code comments. Not about the science proper anyway. It seems to me that there is an attempt to hide something but I'm not quite sure what that is and whether it's of major consequence to the science itself.
However science can estimate from small scale experiments and theoretical calculations a probability that global warming is man-made and its likely effects. Even if the probability of a catastrophe is small, say 5%, it is still worth spending a small percent of GDP to prevent or to ameliorate it. It's like if you own a house you would be an idiot not to spend good money on fire insurance even though the probability of your house burning down is very small.
There is always a question of what the scientific opinion is on climate change. He answers that question pretty well in this post http://forums.xkcd.com/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=15290&st=...
If you don't admit that I have a knife in my pocket, I will kill you.
If you admit I have a knife in my pocket and give me your wallet, I might spare you.
There is strong evidence to suggest that there is a knife in my pocket, but some evidence which may suggest there is no knife.
Are you skeptical by default that there is a knife in my pocket? Can you afford that skepticism?
As such, I advocate policies that attempt to reduce the rate of these changes when possible, until those changes are quite well understood.
I don't worry about "Earth" at all. I worry about food and water security, as well as the enormous waste of resources that will occur if the hydrology of a continent undergoes rapid change and leaves cities, farms and other infrastructure placed inappropriately for the changed climate.
I view this as a conservative and skeptical position.
I find it confusing, and somewhat offensive, that I'm asked by those who advocate unfettered change to prove that their change is deadly, when in most other cases, the person advocating mass change is instead asked to prove that it's safe. It seems particularly problematic, because I'm not advocating a complete halt to the change, but rather a decrease in the derivative of the rate of change.
Edit: Which is a damn good thing, and why I love hanging out here.
"Gore made a mistake on the mosquitoes, what an idiot! and he's fat! har har har! dirty fucking hippies!."
Our grandkids will look upon these people as monsters.
I'm not sure why there is such a big climate-skeptic strain here on HN.