News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by chipgap98 on Thursday July 30, 2015 @12:55PM (#9976286)
I find it interesting that they are investigating them for treason, rather than something like espionage. I know nothing of German law, but it feels like it would be difficult to prove that they betrayed the country
Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by _stephan on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:05PM (#9976357)
See §94 of the German Criminal Code: http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stgb/englisch_stg...

"§94 Treason

(1) Whosoever

1. communicates a state secret to a foreign power or one of its intermediaries; or

2. otherwise allows a state secret to come to the attention of an unauthorised person or to become known to the public in order to prejudice the Federal Republic of Germany or benefit a foreign power and thereby creates a danger of serious prejudice to the external security of the Federal Republic of Germany, shall be liable to imprisonment of not less than one year.

(2) ..."

Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by Tomte on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:12PM (#9976401)
"Landesverrat" is the core paragraph around the espionage complex. It criminalizes (among other things) passing secret information to foreign powers.

As usual when comparing different legal systems it gets muddy. I guess what you're having in mind is more like "Hochverrat" (high treason).

An aside: what are the connotations of "treason" and "treachery" in English? Is treason the criminal act against your country and "treachery" more personal, betraying a friend?

Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by JoshTriplett on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:36PM (#9976567)
> Is treason the criminal act against your country and "treachery" more personal, betraying a friend?

"treachery" is the more general term, that would apply to anything from personal betrayal to particularly underhanded business dealings. It's roughly equivalent to "betrayal", though more emphatic.

"treason" can technically refer to the same thing (you could say "this is treason" to refer to some personal act of betrayal, though it would come across as hyperbole), but in practice it almost exclusively refers to the crime.

Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by chc on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:32PM (#9976536)
"Treachery" just means a deep betrayal of trust. Treason, very bad personal betrayals and things like industrial espionage could all be called treachery without much argument.
Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by escape_goat on Thursday July 30, 2015 @02:31PM (#9976988)
To expand on that, "treachery" emphasizes a connotation of moral judgement that is less explicit in "treason", namely because "treason" is always against the legitimate state (outside of hyperbole), and both the legitimacy of the state and the morality of betraying it are recognized as matters on which opinions may differ. One could be treasonous without being treacherous, or treacherous without being treasonous.

An opinion regarding usage from a native speaker, here: it might for instance be considered treacherous to lure the King into a forest where he may be murdered, in return for a rich reward from a pretender to the throne; but merely supporting the pretender in hopes of a reward, even to the point of secretly betraying the King, might in other circumstances be plainly and distastefully treasonous without evoking the same connotations as treachery.

Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by pekk on Thursday July 30, 2015 @02:29PM (#9976973)
Speaking normally and not legally, treason is against e.g. your country, treachery is more personal. But treachery is more or less just any underhandedness, it isn't necessarily a betrayal of a normative trust like family or friendship or even business obligations. If you were a robber in a band of robbers, and you stole all the money by deceiving them, that would be treachery even if none of you particularly trusted the other. It would also be treachery, in war, to bait the other side by asking for a parley, then killing them.

There are archaic British legal meanings of the word treachery which might parallel your distinction of Landesverrat and Hochverrat, I am not sure. But only lawyers on the Commonwealth side of the fence would likely understand that meaning.

Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by russell on Thursday July 30, 2015 @06:52PM (#9978784)
In the US treason is very narrowly defined by the Constitution to be (paraphrasing) intentionally waging war against the US or aiding the enemy, confirmed by two witnesses to the act. It is quite possible that Snowden could be convicted of espionage but not treason, because we are not waging war with anyone, not even ISIS, therefore we dont have any enemies in this sense. The term treason when used in US politics is nearly always hyperbole.
Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by ObviousScience on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:20PM (#9976443)
Your guess about the connotations is correct.
Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by Tomte on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:41PM (#9976613)
Thanks to all of you!
Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:07PM (#9976370)
"Revealing that we're spying on our citizens" == "betraying the country" - at least in the mind of the powers that be, both in Germany and in the US.

And, in fact, it makes a certain kind of logic. Per dictionary.com, treason means acting to overthrow one's government or trying to harm or kill the sovereign, but it includes giving aid to the enemies of one's government. Revealing where the government is spying on people may in fact give aid to the enemies of the government.

Now, in a free country, that's balanced by the peoples' right to not be spied on by the government. The people have a right to know that the government is crossing that line. (And, in fact, the definition of a free country might be one where the people, rather than the government, are the real sovereign.)

But no, it wouldn't be espionage. Espionage would mean that they were themselves spying, which is not the case.

Re:“Suspicion of treason”: German attorney general investiga... by allendoerfer on Thursday July 30, 2015 @01:07PM (#9976367)
The first thing they will do is to check whether the documents are actually that confidential. It is not like they released anything we were not quite sure about anyway. The government monitors social networks. Surprise!