News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by brlewis on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:40AM (#9968918)
I'm a software engineer. Consequently I have to admit ignorance about this concept of a valid and useful patent. All I ever see is patents that hinder the Progress of Science and useful Arts. Are there really enough valid and useful patents that we should hesitate in our fight against the rest?
Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by acveilleux on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:45AM (#9968964)
There are useful patents though they may hinder more then they help depending on your PoV. Various codecs and some crypto algorithms come to mind.

You run into a lot more useful ones at the intersection with the physical world where some protection lets a company get a chance to be the first one to market and reap some benefit.

In some industries (Pharma) it's really the only practical approach due to the extreme development costs (easily over 1B$) and often cheap production costs.

Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by brlewis on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @02:07PM (#9970444)
To be clear, when I say "patent" I'm referring to a legal instrument that secures exclusive rights. When I say "useful patent" I'm talking about the utility of the legal instrument, not the utility of the mathematical algorithm claimed in the patent.
Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by jebblue on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:44AM (#9968958)
I'm confused, are you asking if you should be fighting patent trolls or patents? If trolls, then fighting them is better than not. Patents are tools, valid and legal, you don't fight tools, you use them, improve them, complain about them, etc.
Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by brlewis on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @11:28AM (#9969240)
I'm talking about patents. Patents are tools in the same sense that landmines are.
Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by sosborn on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @01:38PM (#9970215)
Why choose the word landmine? What's wrong with, say, a hammer?
Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by brlewis on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @02:03PM (#9970415)
Hammers aren't used to exclude people from a path they might otherwise blissfully follow.
Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by ycombobreaker on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @07:11PM (#9972245)
You simply aren't using enough hammers!

Though seriously, I think the term landmine is loaded toward using patents exclusively as a troll. A wider analogy could be like a toll bridge, where the builder should be compensated by travelers. Some tolls could be usurious, but that wouldn't invalidate the whole principle.

Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by sosborn on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:26PM (#9971691)
I guess I disagree with the idea that patents are inherently bad. Like hammers they can be used to build or to destroy.
Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by throwawaykf05 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @02:05PM (#9970436)
Can you explain why you think patents hinder progress of science and the useful arts? How many cases do you know of that people were unable to advance the arts because of a patent? People talk about patent trolls suing startups and main street shops: How many of them actually do anything technically innovative? Hinder commercialization of some old technology? Sure, patents can do that. Stifle progress? Not so much. There are studies on these types of things that you can find on ssrn.com

Your impression is likely based on what you hear in a) tech media, which is largely supported by ads and hence welcome rage-views, and b) tech forums like this where open source is the dominant religion. But count how many times you've heard of a merit-less lawsuit, and compare that to the dark matter of millions of active patents out there. Forming opinions based on cherry picked examples is not a good idea. Better to look at empirical evidence.

I'll give you some numbers less than 1% of patents are ever asserted, and only a fraction of them make it to a trial. The vast majority of patents lie fallow because there is no demand for their technology in the market. Now does that look like a serious problem anymore?

Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by CamperBob2 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @03:26PM (#9971007)
How many cases do you know of that people were unable to advance the arts because of a patent?

For one concrete example, anyone who worked on data compression outside of purely academic areas has been harmed, and by extension their customers have been harmed, by early software patents in that area. The LZW patent (infamously associated with the .GIF file format) and IBM's patents on arithmetic coding both rendered entire fields of computer science radioactive for years.

It's perhaps even more enlightening to spend some thinking about what life would be like if everything that could be patented under the incredibly loose standards of the USPTO was patented. It's safe to say you wouldn't be able to afford the computer or tablet you're typing on, nor the Internet service necessary to convey your thoughts. But this argument is also moot because neither of those technologies would be available in their present form, at any price.

Your impression is likely based on what you hear in a) tech media, which is largely supported by ads and hence welcome rage-views, and b) tech forums like this where open source is the dominant religion.

My impression is based on decades of work in the industry.

I'll give you some numbers less than 1% of patents are ever asserted

How many land mines ever explode? Does that make land mines a good thing? Patents are intellectual land mines, nothing more, nothing less.

Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by throwawaykf05 on Thursday July 30, 2015 @03:30PM (#9977378)
I'm looking at actual data. You are speaking from hearsay and anecdotes. Here's a paper to get started with. It is a review of dozens of papers most of which have empirical results:

http://eml.berkeley.edu//~bhhall/papers/HallHarhoff12_NBER_w...

Your example is not concrete. What you think of as "radioactive" could simply be researchers concluding that specific area was not worth exploring anymore. Here's how you can give a concrete example: Those patents have expired. Can you point to any new fundamentally significant compression technology that has since emerged that could have been thought of as being previously held back by those patents?

Now I can give a concrete example of how those very same patents caused innovation: When they sued people over lzw in gifs, that prompted people to develop alternate methods like PNG. Sounds like progress to me. Was it forced innovation? Sure! But that's always been one of the rationalizations of patents. People often don't innovate unless forced to.

>My impression is based on decades of work in the industry.

So let's get even more anecdotal: how often have you been unable to "advance the arts" due to a patent?

> How many land mines ever explode?

How many good ideas get ripped off with their creator getting nothing in return? If we want to be hyperbolic, I could just say "anti-patent people are just intellectual thieves, nothing more, nothing less"?

Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by brlewis on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @02:16PM (#9970509)
You're looking at the wrong data. Progress is easily impeded without actual lawsuits.

The RSA patent held back crypto progress for decades. I don't know if there were any lawsuits.

Likewise for the GIF patent.

Still today patents on JPEG2000 are preventing its adoption.

H.264 patents slowed progress on web technology. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H.264/MPEG-4_AVC#Controversies

The "dark matter of millions of active patents out there" is an apt description of failure. The constitutional purpose of patents was to disclose inventions that others could build on. If that purpose were being fulfilled we'd be browsing the patent database instead of all the places we actually go when we want to pick up a new technique.

Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by throwawaykf05 on Thursday July 30, 2015 @04:35PM (#9977867)
I extend the same challenge to CamperBob2 above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9977378

Give concrete examples instead of vague generalizations. I just have an example of how the GIF patent actually provoked progress as it was used to sure people who were using it without remuneration to the creators.

Image compression experts say JPEG2000 is simply not used because it's just not enough of an improvement to make it worth the hassle. Patent issues are secondary. And note that patents did not prevent it from bruin developed in the first place.

H.264 patents did not slow down development of new technology, it just slowed adoption of existing technology (h.264) in a different existing environment (browsers) Would you really qualify using the same technology in a browser as a significant technical innovation?

So coming back to my challenge: Now that the RSA patent has expired in 2000, 15 years ago, what novel developments can you point to that you can say was blocked by the patent?

Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by dasil003 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @04:09PM (#9971238)
Your metrics are the percentage of patents asserted and how many make it to trial? You don't even consider the amount of settlements that happened for obvious universal technologies, or perhaps more importantly the number of uses of a patent to implement something useful which could not have been developed independently.

You're asking to assume patents are useful until proven otherwise, and waving your hands about cherry-picking, when in fact you'd have to cherry-pick pretty severely to find an example of a software patent which would stand up to an honest evaluation of its novelty. This is because software is not created by lone inventors having eureka moments behind closed doors—the state of the art is pushed forward primarily through massive collaboration. The vast majority of software patents only exist because software and mathematics are arcane topics that the patent office doesn't have the expertise to understand or the incentive to evaluate honestly.

Software patents and IP are not natural laws with inherent value. It is not for us to empirically prove their harm, rather they are specific legal constructs designed for the public good, and thus their good must be justified, not the other way around.

Re:Newegg vs. Patent Trolls: When We Win, You Win by darkarmani on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @04:16PM (#9971281)
> I'll give you some numbers less than 1% of patents are ever asserted, and only a fraction of them make it to a trial. The vast majority of patents lie fallow because there is no demand for their technology in the market. Now does that look like a serious problem anymore?

It sounds like you are arguing to abolish patents. The rest of the world is held hostage for under 1% of the patents issued? It doesn't sound like a serious problem to just do away with then all according to your stats.