News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the cruelty of really teaching computer science (1988) by JadeNB on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:31AM (#9968852)
> And so we produce programmers who are helpless without formal functional specifications, and are therefore incapable of writing any software in the real world, with conflicting, underspecified, and post-hoc requirements.

That … doesn't seem like a problem that exists in the world as it exists (but see the caveat below on my qualification to make such statements). It seems like the real world of programming is so full of people who are so used to conflicting, underspecified, and post hoc requirements that it doesn't occur to them that there is any other way, and so we live in a world in which it is simply assumed that software doesn't actually work as it is supposed to do, even if only in edge cases. Should all software be formally specified? No, and I'm sure that, despite his passion for overstatement, even Dijkstra didn't think so—but I think that the programming world would probably be a better place if more programmers were aware of the potential and possibility of formalisation, and so could introduce and take advantage of it as appropriate.

> But more importantly: this sucks all of the joy out of it! Who here got into programming out of a passion for translating formal functional specifications into formal proofs?

Me! I think it's not fair to assume that everyone enjoys programming for the same reason that you do, any more than it would be for Dijkstra to assume that others do or should for the same reason that he did. To be fair, though, I'm a mathematician, not a professional programmer.

There are no comments on this comment yet.