Re:Ask HN: Excel experts – Formula IDE in Excel (MVP screens...
by zhte415 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:21AM
(#9968782)
>> Users don't buy plugins in larger businesses, etc.
>Fact or opinion?
Users definitely buy plugins, but these bring significant functionality and often tie-in to additional services. Financial data being the most familiar to me. These plugins, while wrapped in VBA, are often in C++ (again, finance world) for robustness and performance, and try to be as agnostic to whatever nutty layout or logic a user chooses to have for their spreadsheet.
So, agree, with the pragmatic assertion that technical people love Excel as a UI, but they're probably not necessarily developer-technical (could be, given the richness of Excel plugins can have on some platforms), but technical in another field and Excel is an easily hackable UI for what they really want to do, which is mainly, as the OP suggests, using Excel to change stuff and do what-ifs, which spreadsheets were designed to do (as if, to close the circle).
>Fact or opinion?
Users definitely buy plugins, but these bring significant functionality and often tie-in to additional services. Financial data being the most familiar to me. These plugins, while wrapped in VBA, are often in C++ (again, finance world) for robustness and performance, and try to be as agnostic to whatever nutty layout or logic a user chooses to have for their spreadsheet.
So, agree, with the pragmatic assertion that technical people love Excel as a UI, but they're probably not necessarily developer-technical (could be, given the richness of Excel plugins can have on some platforms), but technical in another field and Excel is an easily hackable UI for what they really want to do, which is mainly, as the OP suggests, using Excel to change stuff and do what-ifs, which spreadsheets were designed to do (as if, to close the circle).