News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mobile Safari's Performance Is Not the Problem by Retric on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:19AM (#9968761)
Google does not trust sites as many will fake their numbers to make more from Ads. If Google directly talks to each user's IP it's much easier for Google to tell that each page load was a real page load.

In your approach they are stuck trusting the webserver and it's far easier to add fake page loads, this is somewhat less of an issue with PPC, but there are still issues.

On top of that advertisers want to track each user which is far simpler when it's a separate HTTP request.

Re:Mobile Safari's Performance Is Not the Problem by vbezhenar on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:37AM (#9968896)
> Google does not trust sites not to fake their numbers. If Google directly talks to each user IP it's much easier for Google to tell that each page load was a real page load.

If we're talking about Google Analytics, the user wants to view correct data in the first place.

> In your approach they are stuck trusting the webserver and it's far easier to add fake page loads, this is somewhat less of an issue with PPC, but there are still issues.

That's true.

> On top of that advertisers want to track a user which is far simpler when it's a separate HTTP request.

Webserver is supposed to send all necessary user's data to Google server (like IP, UA, Cookies) and Google might ask Webserver to set google-specific Cookie.

Cross-site tracking won't be possible, that's true. Probably some standard could be invented for that (e.g. Google signs global inter-site cookie to deliver to the user and browser should send this cookie to all Google-enabled sites). That'll make easier for user to disable tracking, if user wants that.

My point is that if Google doesn't want to improve their scheme, may be other advertising company will want to improve that scheme. And Google might realize that users will follow that company, that's what competition is about.

And probably Google itself is not the evil here. There are many other ad networks with huge banners and slow loading scripts.

Re:Mobile Safari's Performance Is Not the Problem by glass- on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @11:00AM (#9969061)
Google Analytics had a self-hosted version, or more specifically Google Analytics was a self-hosted solution when it was Urchin before Google acquired it.

You could still get the self-hosted version for a price until Google killed it in 2012.

The reason Google doesn't want you to do this is simple: they want the data.

Re:Mobile Safari's Performance Is Not the Problem by Jgrubb on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @10:26AM (#9968813)
Not to mention the algorithms and business behind which ad to serve where and when are worthy of an entire field of study all by themselves.

Read the Advertising chapter in Mining Massive Datasets - http://www.mmds.org/ - and then figure out how you'd tackle those problems when you distribute them onto other people's servers.