News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by gaius on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @11:30AM (#996775)
Meh, it looks the same as any other airliner. Where're the radical designs, a la Concorde (delta), Comet (engines in wings) etc etc? Boeing's just making tweaks to a basic design that's been around since the 1960s.
Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by rbanffy on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @12:13PM (#996880)
Neither approach (delta wings, in-wing-engine) worked out well.

Delta wings are great in supersonic flight, but not so in shorter distances and for takeoff and landing. The Concorde is a beautiful machine, but not a terribly practical one. I miss it, BTW.

Comet-style in-wing engines cannot use silent and efficient turbofan designs and would need fat wings to accommodate the engines, increasing drag. The position of the engine exhaust also limits the efficiency of the wing and the effectiveness of the control surfaces.

Radical designs require more engineering than any airplane manufacturer can afford right now. It's not like airlines will dump all their 747s and 380s (and all other 7x7s and A3xxs) just because there is a more efficient plane rolling out of the factory line. Airplanes are horribly expensive and have a very long service life.

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by gvb on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @11:50AM (#996820)
The radical design is under the skin. OK, in and under the skin. "Its materials (by weight) are: 50% composite, 20% aluminum, 15% titanium, 10% steel, 5% other." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/787_Dreamliner#Features

The Concorde had a delta wing so it could fly supersonically with acceptable range (fuel economy vs. tankage). The trade-off for that speed was horrible fuel economy and poor takeoff and landing characteristics (extremely high drag - it had to use afterburners to get airborne).

WRT the Comet, airframers don't put engines in wings because they are a bugger to service there.

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by notauser on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @12:32PM (#996920)
A big part of the reason for hanging the engines is actually because it means you can make the wings less robust.

If you have in-wing engines they generally have to be near the root (where the wing connects to the fuselage) because engines are large, wings taper and wings shouldn't be too fat. Under wing engines can be hung wherever you like, within reason.

If you simplify things a bit you can think of a wing as a cantilever which supports half the weight of the plane, balanced by an equal upwards force spread out along the whole wing.

By shifting weight towards the middle of the wing, as you can do by moving an engine outboard, some of your weight is no longer at the end of the lever but instead is closer (on average) to where the upwards force is being applied. This decreases the load you have to design for even though the weight remains the same.

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by borism on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @02:39PM (#997207)
Engines are not just "hanged wherever one likes". There's an optimal point along the wing where airflow entering the engine will provide optimal performance, and it's not near the wing root.
Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by notauser on Wednesday December 16, 2009 @03:22AM (#998345)
It's pretty much a given that anything you read about aerodynamics on an Internet forum will be a massive generalization made to illustrate a simplified version of the point.

Look at the rubbish people keep on repeating about the reasons for inherent instability for a prime example!

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by InclinedPlane on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @12:42PM (#996951)
Your comment is a good example of how not to communicate effectively.

You pose a "question" in such a condescending and dismissive tone that leaves no room for fallibility in your assumptions or your knowledge, no reasonable answer other than "hurr, of course you're right and Boeing is teh dumbs" is possible without introducing conflict. If instead of taking a confrontational tone you took an inquisitive, deprecatory route of acknowledging that you lack perfect knowledge of aerospace design and are curious exactly why the 787 is considered so radical a design, given the seeming lack of outward differences of appearance from existing planes, you would perhaps start an engaging, informative discussion.

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by gaius on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @12:54PM (#996974)
My point is purely an aesthetic one. This is what Boeing could have done:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Sonic_Cruiser

Now that's beautiful. It looks like a Skylon:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaction_Engines_Skylon

Instead it looks the same as every other airliner.

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by gvb on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @02:50PM (#997233)
Boeing shopped the Sonic Cruiser concept extensively to the airlines. The premise of the Sonic Cruiser was a 15-20% increase in speed (Mach 0.95-0.98) without increasing the fuel burn rate.

The airlines said "no thanks, give us 15-20% lower fuel burn rate at the current speed" (Mach 0.85). The 787 was the result... the form follows the function.

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by cabalamat on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @02:30PM (#997170)
You think Boeing should design planes based on how cool they look? Myself, I'd rather that any plane I travelled in was designed by competent auronautical engineers.
Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by gaius on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @03:50PM (#997390)
Are you saying the Sonic Cruiser was incompetently designed? I'm pretty sure it was the same team that later did the 787...
Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by cabalamat on Wednesday December 16, 2009 @08:39PM (#1000200)
> Are you saying the Sonic Cruiser was incompetently designed?

No. If it had been designed on the basis of looking cool, it would have been. And probably wouldn't have flown.

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by borism on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @02:36PM (#997193)
look closer! you don't have to know anything about composite structure etc. just take a thoughtful look and you'll understand that it's not your usual airliner (although it is very similar in many ways)!

I'm sure they have plenty of supersonic airliner designs lying around, but I'm afraid you're not prepared to pay for a ticket to fly on one ;)

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by jedc on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @11:50AM (#996825)
Radical designs are in manufacturing (ie, massive use of composites) rather than aerodynamics.

And that "basic design" has had a lot of efficiencies made to it in the last 50 years. I'd be highly surprised if there were any potential design changes left that could make a visible difference. (Ignoring things like lifting bodies that would drastically change the passenger experience.)

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by run4yourlives on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @12:28PM (#996908)
Like all design, the more radical, the more risk.

While it would be awesome to see a canard design, which would be the most logical choice given fuel costs and safety, the odds of a struggling airline manufacturer introducing something so risky are extremely low.

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by gills on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @04:15PM (#997437)
Software guy: "Here's your new efficient CRM server!"

Pointy-haired guy: "Where's teh xml? Where's teh 3D? Your software is lame and from the 1960s."

Really?

Re:Boeing 787 First Flight Today 10AM PT by gaius on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @04:52PM (#997532)
It's more like the boss asked for a website and the programmer delivered a greenscreen.