News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by creshal on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @04:19AM (#9967045)
It's not fully clear whether the German government has jurisdiction here, with Facebook nominally residing in Ireland. A case has just been filed by the Hamburg state government, but that can easily take years to go through courts.

> How can a government have jurisdiction over this?

Because the government can decide that demanding a driver's license is illegal because it is an unreasonable burden on users, simple as that. German law states it must be possible to use a service anonymously or pseudonymously "if it is technically possible and reasonable". Whether it is reasonable in this particular case is for the courts to decide. (cf. Telemediengesetz, http://www.cgerli.org/index.php?id=51&tx_vmdocumentsearch_pi... )

Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by _ak on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:25AM (#9967328)
Facebook is operating in Germany, among other countries. If they want to earn money in Germany, they need to obey to German laws and regulations, obviously.
Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by creshal on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:27AM (#9967342)
With the internet being the poorly regulated series of tubes it is, they argue they're operating and earning money solely in Ireland, not Germany. Whether the judge will be amused by this, we'll see.
Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by _ak on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:35AM (#9967373)
They operate offices in Hamburg and Berlin. They specifically target German advertisers. They won't be that stupid to even attempt that argument.
Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by pjc50 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:45AM (#9967422)
They already have argued that the datacentre is in Ireland and therefore not subject to this ruling. Again, we await a jurisdiction ruling.
Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by creshal on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:53AM (#9967463)
They did – publicly, at least. We'll see what they argue in court.
Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by rbehrends on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @06:34AM (#9967639)
> It's not fully clear whether the German government has jurisdiction here, with Facebook nominally residing in Ireland.

The Schleswig-Holstein data protection authority lost a case against Facebook in 2013 because the court ruled that Germany didn't have jurisdiction. However, the Google Spain case last year changed that pretty decisively. It's difficult to see (after Google lost before the CJEU) why Germany should not have jurisdiction in this case.

Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by DanBC on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:35AM (#9967372)
> It's not fully clear whether the German government has jurisdiction here, with Facebook nominally residing in Ireland.

Facebook has offices in London and Hamburg so "operating out of Ireland" is a bit of a stretch that seems to work with tax authorities, but may not work with other law enforcement.

Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by personjerry on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @04:27AM (#9967075)
That makes sense, thank you for explaining the particular details.
Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by mseebach on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:27AM (#9967339)
They can decide all that, but that doesn't give them clear jurisdiction to actually enforce it. They can penalise users doing it, possibly by making it a breach of the terms of carrying a drivers license to use it for this purpose, although it's not clear how they'd prove such usage.

Alternatively, they can try to hit Facebook's ad sales in Germany, but that's likely to run into common market rules around trade barriers.

Anyway, does Facebook actually enforce this? I have never shown any ID to Facebook, and I see plenty of people not using their real names (typically they use derivatives or add a screenname as a middle name, rather than being totally pseudonymous).

Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by Broken_Hippo on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:52AM (#9967458)
"Does facebook actually enforce this?" .... The answer to this question is a loud "yes". The harderst hit groups I've found are transgender folks and occultists. As far as being pagan/occultist, many prefer to keep a seperate account for their religious lives, partially because many live in places where they would be persecuted. In addition, many have a magical name that is part of their chosen religion, that they prefer to be addressed by in such circles.

The result of the real name policy, outside of taking away individual privacy, has been the shutting down of accounts, forcing people to provide identifacation, phone numbers, etc, to prove you are you, and insisting that the name matches the legal name. Some people never really seem to be able to unlock the original account (or don't want to give facebook ID)

Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by Symbiote on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:58AM (#9967489)
Facebook completely enforces this, but only acts on profiles that are reported to them.

Around a year ago, many of my friends were in a "Gay Pride 2014 parade" group. Over two or three days, everyone in that group with a fake-looking name was reported. A little later, everyone who had 'liked' a local gay nightclub page was reported.

The obvious conclusion was someone with an agenda was searching particular groups for people to report.

Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by pjc50 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @11:39AM (#9969328)
This is another example of a theoretically neutral policy being used to enable harrasment, because it's not applied in a uniform manner.
Re:Facebook Ordered by Hamburg Regulator to Allow Pseudonyms by pjc50 on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @05:47AM (#9967426)
They can issue a court order, and if Facebook were to go full "freemen of the land" and try to ignore it there's always the European Arrest Warrant.