Re:On the cruelty of really teaching computer science (1988)
by pdonis on Wednesday July 29, 2015 @12:00AM
(#9966081)
> Einstein's formulas showed him that the universe was expanding.
More precisely, they showed him that there was no solution describing a static universe; the universe would have to be either expanding or contracting. Nothing in the math gave any reason to favor expansion over contraction; it's just that, since we now know the universe is expanding, that's the possibility we always focus on when talking about this episode.
> He didn't trust what his own formulas, which were radical at the time, were showing him
I don't think it was that he didn't trust the formulas; he had already explored other solutions that were giving correct predictions. It was just that he thought the universe should be static, so he didn't like the fact that there wasn't a static solution to his original equations.
> Observations by astronomers like Hubble later showed him that his original formulas were correct
More precisely, they showed that the universe was expanding, so there was no need to insist on having a static solution to the equations. But, as FreeFull pointed out, we now know that there is a nonzero cosmological constant, so Einstein's original equations, without that constant, weren't quite correct anyway.
More precisely, they showed him that there was no solution describing a static universe; the universe would have to be either expanding or contracting. Nothing in the math gave any reason to favor expansion over contraction; it's just that, since we now know the universe is expanding, that's the possibility we always focus on when talking about this episode.
> He didn't trust what his own formulas, which were radical at the time, were showing him
I don't think it was that he didn't trust the formulas; he had already explored other solutions that were giving correct predictions. It was just that he thought the universe should be static, so he didn't like the fact that there wasn't a static solution to his original equations.
> Observations by astronomers like Hubble later showed him that his original formulas were correct
More precisely, they showed that the universe was expanding, so there was no need to insist on having a static solution to the equations. But, as FreeFull pointed out, we now know that there is a nonzero cosmological constant, so Einstein's original equations, without that constant, weren't quite correct anyway.