So, the question is: do you want countries that either don't care about humanitarian values, or only pretend to care, to have an upper hand compared to countries that can not only pass such laws, but also to enforce it?
We have nothing to worry about. This is the same kind of reasoning many use to exclaim that terrorism is a threat to the United States. Really? http://www.state.gov/j/ct/rls/crt/2014/239418.htm
{{citation-needed}}
http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/310301/how-was-the-f..., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourier_analysis#History
This only works if you can ensure that everybody obeys the law. You can't. The primary threat here is not some rogue militia in the US building autonomous weapons; it's a country like Iran or North Korea, that doesn't give a rat's ass about laws, building autonomous weapons.
My assumption is that open letters only work on people who are willing to rationally discuss alternatives. The countries you mentioned probably don't care about anything.
I'd like to see change at least in the US. I'm not worried about "rouge" militia either, I'm worried about the Army et al.
Probably not much.
The human need to assign blame to a single source is an evolutionary remnant that we should be aware of and try to correct for, rather than embracing it. Just because something is terrible doesn't mean you can put all the blame for it on one person or group of people.
Because if you have someone pulling the trigger, you know who's to blame. But if a computer's doing it, it's oh-so-easy to shift blame.
Honestly, with that requirement in place, either AI weapons will never be implemented (because they can't prevent wrongful deaths) or they'll be perfectly implemented (making the world safer, possibly).
Passing a law like that could possibly lead to a win-win situation.