Given that this is a 700W microwave oven putting out a tiny amount of thrust, and that a positive finding would invalidate a basic conservation law, my money is on those wires.
I also have a strong gut feeling that this some none issue but it never hurts to test it the US, Russia, China and to lesser Extent the UK, France and other European powers have all conducted studies into ESP, the cost of such testing is ridiculously low compared to the potential discovery.
When it costs near to nothing to explore a phenomenon that can change how we understand physics it's worth exploring no matter how ridiculous it is.
I think that the best metric is to compare this with the maximal Force/Power ratio that is consistent with a "massless" thruster and special relativity, (i.e. a laser beam, photon thruster, ...). In this case the Force/Power ratio is at most 1/c, that is 0.0033 uN/W = 0.0033 mN/KW.
The results in the table vary from 3x to 200000x the theoretical maximum if we assume that this doesn't break the conservation of momentum, special relativity and quantum mechanics.
Uh oh. That's a classic sign of a bogus effect. It's like physicists at Stanford trying to replicate the Pons-Fleischmann cold fusion experiment. At first, they were enthusiastic, and expected big results. They started out with the apparatus surrounded with radiation alarms in case it generated dangerous amounts of neutrons. After a while, they discovered that the effect was at most twice background radiation. Since humans have water in them and water is a neutron reflector, just moving around the equipment could produce effects at that level. Then they moved the equipment to the inside of a cube of lead bricks, to eliminate external neutrons. No more neutrons, background or otherwise.
The device will either be shown to work or not to work with additional experiments and nothing anyone says regarding how it can or can't work will change that.
I haven't studied the theory behind the device, but it's hardly a distortion to characterize such a disproportionate drop as a declining effect size in the face of additional testing.
Like you, I don't claim to have any idea whether this ultimately pans out. As I said, the ultimate test is to put one in space and see what it does. Until that (or at least a more promising lab test) happens, all we have is speculation. But my point is that more skepticism is warranted than was implied by the Wired headline and by some of the comments in this thread.
http://www.you-tech.it/index.php/content/download/12369/1124...
On the other hand, the decrease in effect size is closer to a factor of 40,000.
Right now my guess is either measurement artifact or some form of obscure but conventional effect like EM interaction with the surround environment. That's most likely.
If those can be ruled out, then we're in new physics territory.
You're forgetting mass-energy equivalence. <x> energy / <y> thrust is a specific impulse, once you work in the factor of c^2 (that being the minimum amount of mass you need to burn to get the energy to produce the thrust.)
In this case, for instance, they are saying they think it produced 20 uN with an input of 700w. That works out to an effective specific impulse of 2.5x10^9m/s as an upper limit (yes, this is tachyonic. One of the problems with this drive is that it throws conservation of energy and momentum out the window...), assuming we could convert mass to energy directly. (If you're using D-T fusion, it's a specific impulse of ~9.7x10^6m/s instead as an upper limit, assuming 339.72 TJ/kg. Other reactions are lower.)
If you're assuming solar panels or some other external power source, then the only real difference between this and a laser is that this produces a constant factor more thrust per energy input. Sure, it's reactionless - but, effectively, so is a neutrino source, for instance. All that means is that you don't need to be as careful as to which direction you burn in.
I'm sure someone will put the cash together eventually if the dirtside experiments look promising, but there's no sense in risking the money until we're pretty sure.
After all, it will either sit there and do nothing or it will move.
Solar sails and (to an extent) ion thrusters work on the same principle.
http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/abs/10.2514/6.2015-4083
High levels of skepticism are still warranted, as much as I would love for this to pan out. Every time this gets tested—presumably more and more carefully—the measured force gets smaller. The original test at Chinese Northwestern Polytechnical University measured 720 mN; this latest test in a vacuum chamber, only 20 μN. This is so tiny that a test anomaly would seem a much more plausible explanation than a violation of the conservation of momentum.
Of course the ultimate test would be to put one of these in space and try accelerating something with it, in the same way that the ultimate test of a perpetual motion machine would be to make one perform macro-scale net work.