Re:The Craigslist Lawsuit
by rayiner on Saturday July 25, 2015 @10:47PM
(#9949949)
I didn't know about the Google Cache thing. The Wiki page doesn't mention it. That definitely changes at least the CFAA part of the case. Did they ever scrape CL directly?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
"the policy of 3taps with regards to Craigslist data is that any sourcing of that data for insertion via our API be done without scraping or visiting Craigslist at all." (original emphasis)
Obviously, I don't know whether they followed that policy. However, the important point is that it sounds like Craigslist's argument applies regardless of whether 3taps was scraping directly from CL.
Here's the source: https://3taps.com/papers/response%20to%20%20c_n_d%20letter%2...
yes, both padmapper and 3taps were scraping CL directly for some of the time
padmapper was scraping, got C&D, so moved to 3taps
3taps got C&D (and was playing dumb games like switching ip addresses to avoid blocks), then moved to scraping CL posts out of google's cache, claiming they therefore weren't bound by terms and conditions of CL. After CL blocked google from caching posts, 3taps went back to scraping CL.
Was blocking caching on Google what he referred to as "interfering with Google and other search engines"? That's laying it thick.
Ultimately, 3taps knew they were wrong no matter how many ways they try to justify it. For all of their time and energy, they should have just built a new craigslist.
Read the link. The details of this are in there.
After they were told to C&D and sued by Craigslist, they decided to try a cute workaround and pull the Craigslist listings from cached Google copies instead, which didn't quite work out so well for them in the end.