Re:Microsoft rips off Plurk
by axod on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:12PM
(#994500)
Read the article. They did.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I just pretty-printed the largest JS file loaded in their homepage. The result doesn't look obfuscated by any means.
Removing whitespace != Obfuscating
Don't take their claims at face-value, get your facts straight.
Disclaimer: I'm not claiming that obfuscating (or not) makes any difference with regards to MS infringing on their codebase, just pointing out that it's not actually very obfuscated as claimed by their developer.
I just re-read the article. If you really squint you might be able to assume that their code was scrambled in some way (if that's what "not compiled" means). Otherwise if you're trying to gain (well deserved) sympathy for something like this then the deobfuscation process is probably the most important part of the story. Did MS then rescramble the code? I'd want to know that as well.
You are more concerned about obfuscation of code than the fact that a major software developer ripped of someone's code, is a little troubling.
Whether he obfuscation code or not has absolutely zero importance in this context.
Of course it has context if this is being presented as a legal issue. The original article doesn't really mention it (although it's easier to assume now with the hindsight of a complete comment thread). I believe you are "even more guilty" if you de-obfuscate someone's code, then copy and republish/reuse.
There is no such thing as "more guilty". You are or you aren't.
It indicates intent and state of mind. "More guilty" is just an expression that means "more evidence for guilt."
OK - I can see what you mean. However, I still disagree. De-obfuscation does not provide more evidence that infringement occurred, it simply implies that whoever did it likely knew they should not be doing it, which has (I believe) absolutely no legal implication.