News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by grellas on Monday December 14, 2009 @11:56AM (#994450)
The technology associated with film-making has evolved incrementally ever since its inception: from the 1890's Edison Kinetoscope shorts that could be watched by only one person at a time to the 2-reeler comedy shorts circa 1915 to D.W. Griffith's breakthrough with silent feature-length films in Birth of a Nation to the first talkies with 1927's The Jazz Singer to the introduction of color in select 1920's movies such as The Black Pirate (eventually evolving into beautiful technicolor productions) to Disney's feature animations in the 1930's to the first experimentation with 3-D in the 1950's with The Blue Lagoon and other gimmick films featuring knives and other assorted objects being hurled gratuitously at the audience to the widescreen film techniques of the 1950's featuring elongated landscapes that made one dizzy watching them to the modern digital special effects movies featuring CGI in a leading role.

Throughout this history, film-makers have continually experimented with different camera techniques and different types of cameras.

This item relating to Mr. Cameron appears to be another incremental step in this long process. It looks to be interesting and possibly intriguing.

What is being lost in the modern film innovations, however, is what I would call the essence of film-making, which is a play-acted script featuring real people but presented as human drama/comedy/satire/etc. using the recognized camera techniques that distinguish cinema from a live play - rapid cutting, point-of-view camera angles, etc. As things go increasingly digital, and become more and more subject to manipulation of images bearing less and less connection with our real world experiences, we get more and more a sense of watching a cartoon as opposed to real people. It is no coincidence that, in this context, many of the modern plots are drawn from cartoon sources (Batman, Spider Man, many others). As this emphasis on special effects has increased, what has become increasingly lost is the quality scripts (with their corresponding wit, drama, fantasy) that once could be taken for granted in quality film-making. The result is an increasingly artificial experience to which it becomes harder and harder to relate.

Over the centuries, it is the great stories that have moved us, from epic poems to the great novels and, yes, even to the cinema of old warhorses such as Gone with the Wind. Today, technology has become as much a substitute for story-telling as anything else. Yes, it constitutes progress in a real sense (incremental though it may be) but, insofar as it has detracted from inspiring story-telling by serving as a tin-hat means of attracting audiences without the need to develop a great story, it has brought a net loss. Just watch a silent movie like Sunrise (1927) and tell me that CGI and other gimmicks have brought a net improvement to what truly can be inspiring about film.

It is, of course, possible to combine great new technology with great stories but not when the technology itself is being featured as the primary attraction.

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by roc on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:09PM (#995101)
I don't buy the argument that the past had a higher rate of quality scripts. To me, that position has always smacked of selective reporting combined with the old 'back in my day' argument.

The undeniably great stories of western civilization total a hundred or so works over the course of our history. So the works of any given decade or generation will always be found wanting in that comparison. It shows nothing.

If anything, the old studio system was designed to shovel out disposable content even more so than the current configuration.

Now I don't have a comprehensive study to support my position, but until commonly accepted wisdom has one for its stance, I disagree.

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by cchooper on Monday December 14, 2009 @07:17PM (#995490)
These days, the commonly accepted wisdom is that movies were always as bad as they are now, and anyone who says otherwise is just idealizing the past. I offer the following evidence that the quality of movies is not constant over time:

1939: Mr. Smith Goes To Washington, Gone With The Wind, The Wizard Of Oz, Stagecoach, Ninotchka, Wuthering Heights

1940: Rebecca, Fantasia, His Girl Friday, The Grapes of Wrath, The Philadelphia Story, The Great Dictator

1941: Citizen Kane, The Maltese Falcon, The Lady Eve, Sullivan's Travels

Rather than relying on personal taste, I took these from various 'top 100' lists. I haven't seen all of them myself, but the ones I have seen are a mile apart from anything released this year, or any recent year.

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by NikkiA on Thursday December 17, 2009 @05:55PM (#1002138)
IMDB reports that 2322 movies were released in 1939 alone, is it really surprising that there were a handful of good movies among them?

1980 for comparision, IMDB lists 6007 movies (8000+ if you include TV movies), and contains modern (popular) classics such as Stir Crazy, Superman II, Empire Strikes Back, Airplane!, The Blue Lagoon, Ordinary People, Urban Cowboy. The Shining, Caddyshack, Raging Bull, Friday The 13th, The Fog, The Blues Brothers.

Hmm, looks like 1980 was a much more 'classic' era than the 40s for hollywood, but you wouldn't have heard that from film buffs in the 80s.

Hollywood has always been a great abuser of the 'sling lots of shit at the wall and see what sticks' approach to 'greatness', they're just slinging a lot more shit these days.

Even if we take a really contemporary year and do the same study, we see a pattern of greats no matter what year, take 2005 at random:

Batman Begins, Sin City, V for Vendetta, Revenge of the Sith, King Kong, Brokeback Mountain, Harry Potter/Goblet of Fire, Serenity, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Mr & Mrs Smith, Wedding Crashers, Munich, Saw 2, Hostel, Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, Madagascar, Pride & Prejudice, Land of the Dead.

Ah, but the movie buff will point out that they're not established classics like Gone with the Wind, or Wizard of Oz. Not yet, anyway.

Edit: Btw, for 2005, the number of movies was 28,000+. Is it any wonder that there is a lot of formulaic stuff in there as well?

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by cchooper on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @07:07AM (#1011951)
There is not a single great movie in your 2005 list. In fact Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is one of the worst movies I've ever seen.

As for the 1980s, this was indeed a much better decade than the current one. The 70s were even better, much better than the 40s.

> is it really surprising that there were a handful of good movies among them?

Not good movies, great movies.

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by roc on Wednesday December 16, 2009 @10:58AM (#999002)
I guess it depends on who you're talking to. I still keep hearing 'movies used to be better'.

And I never argued that quality was constant. I believe it's essentially random. So the existence of an aberrant concentration of quality isn't surprising to me. I'm sure you could find clusters of a few years where nothing of note came out as well.

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by grellas on Monday December 14, 2009 @05:58PM (#995357)
Your basic points are good ones with which I don't disagree (the studio system did turn out a lot of junk and classic story-telling does stand in a class by itself). Insofar as I implied otherwise in favor of what might have come across as a nostalgic view of the past, I stand corrected.

If I were to rephrase my basic point, I would say that (in my view) technology, however good, is less important to good film-making than are other creative elements such as good story-telling. Thus, if film producers have limited resources to devote to a project and pour most of them into expensive technology as opposed to paying for quality scripts, story lines can and do suffer, as do the films associated with them. I think that has happened a lot in recent years but will grant that it is subjective on my part (there are, of course, a good number of original, quality scripts around in today's movies, with Pixar's output coming to mind among others).

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by roc on Tuesday December 15, 2009 @02:25PM (#997155)
"technology, however good, is less important to good film-making than are other creative elements such as good story-telling"

Yes, well, I agree with that part. 110%. Possibly more.

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by pronoiac on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:21PM (#994826)
What? You did not just diss comics.

Big dumb blockbusters have a quality of their own. Big budgets & mass appeal can easily seem to demand a bland inoffensiveness, but so don't watch them if you're in the mood for a smarter movie. There are still a few out there. And calling out for a time when films were Quality just strikes me as convenient nostalgia, ignoring past crap.

Re:James Cameron’s New 3-D Epic Could Change Film Forever by sp332 on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:05PM (#995372)
GP didn't dis comics, he's dissing filmmakers who can't tell the difference between a comic and a movie.