News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by gaius on Monday December 14, 2009 @11:54AM (#994444)
It's not us you need to tell Joel, it's your business partner. And if this is your way of telling him, isn't it a little passive-aggressive to do it in a blog post?
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by spolsky on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:18PM (#994517)
I think that a lot of people think they have backups, but they've never restored them, so I thought it would be a good practice if everyone starting thinking in terms of "have we restored" rather than "are we backing up." Of course, there's no question that the thought process started when Jeff Atwood's personal blog was lost, but don't think for a minute that the only way I communicate with him is by blogging... we talk all the time, over skype, over email, over FogBugz, and sometimes, when there's something other people can learn, in public on the internet.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by telemachos on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:22PM (#994526)
The weird part is not that you made a blog post about this issue now.

The weird part is that you didn't mention the 400 pound gorilla in the room. ("I've been thinking about this for a long time, but it really hit home recently when...")

To my mind, that's why the post seems odd or passive aggressive. (It's a relatively short post as well. It just feels clipped somehow. The reader inevitably says, "What's not here?")

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by mechanical_fish on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:30PM (#994542)
It may be difficult to remember now that Twitter is all the rage, but essayists often aim for that "timeless" quality. You want the essay to seem as relevant three years from now as it is today.

The web has more than enough content that feels stale after a week. Better to aim for something with a slightly longer shelf life.

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by pyre on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:05PM (#994633)
Yea, but how is "my friend/business partner recently lost his entire blog due to poor backups, and it got me thinking..." not 'timeless?'
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by forensic on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:09PM (#995100)
To be honest, I don't give a shit about his friend/business partner.

But I do like his idea. So I appreciate that he omits pointless personal details and just sticks to the meat of the article.

When a writer expects me to read a bunch of self-indulgent cliche boilerplate I usually hit the back button.

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by mattmanser on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:27PM (#994844)
Not poor backups, poor restores. You're missing the point of the article!
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by oscardelben on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:43PM (#994886)
It's also poor backup. They thought the backup was being done by their hosting company while in reality it was failing silently.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by Periodic on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:56PM (#994930)
A good backup is one that can be restored.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by pyre on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:15PM (#995386)
A poor backup becomes a poor restore, while a good backup isn't necessarily a good restore. It's like quibbling over whether I said, "his car was completely totaled in the race" rather than, "he didn't win the race." No one thinks that not crashing your car implies that you've won a race, but you can't win a race with a crashed car.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by nollidge on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:08PM (#994783)
This doesn't make any sense. Unless you have some other reason to suspect there's animosity between them, why would you invent drama between the lines?
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by mistermann on Monday December 14, 2009 @03:08PM (#994964)
Check the URL in your browser....and the author of the article being discussed. Sufficient explanation for anything that will transpire here.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by flogic on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:03PM (#994630)
It's generally better if you try to avoid putting your business partners or employees down in public.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by bhousel on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:54PM (#994607)
"Let’s stop asking people if they’re doing backups, and start asking if they’re doing restores."

No, because restores wouldn't have helped Jeff Atwood. You can backup a database onto the same server that hosts the database, and still successfully restore it later.

We should instead be talking about the concept of Continuity of Business. Decide how important it is for your data to continue to be available (constant availability vs. several days downtime vs. don't care if it disappears entirely?), then make a plan that gives you that availability.

What I'm describing isn't necessarily complicated. For example, I keep all my backup data (photos, music, etc) on a USB drive. Every morning it's rsynced to a hot spare. Every few weeks, I swap the spare with another one in a safe deposit box at the bank. (This means that we can recover from both immediate accidental deletions, and also ones that we don't catch for a few days, and disasters like theft or fire). I check every few days to make sure the drives are still working, and my wife knows how to switch the drives and has a key to the safe deposit box, just in case something happens to me.

Anyway, we feel that these are appropriate steps for protecting the data that we don't want to lose. But the important point is that everyone should make a plan that's appropriate for them.

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by spolsky on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:14PM (#994654)
In the article, I wrote

"If you’re running a web service, you need to be able to show me that you can build a reasonably recent copy of the entire site, in a reasonable amount of time, on a new server or servers without ever accessing anything that was in the original data center."

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by nomoresecrets on Monday December 14, 2009 @04:37PM (#995172)
Yes, in many ways, Jeff 'took one for the team' in a big way, in that he reminded a lot of people to "Er...I'll just check my backups and make sure they're working."

We're tech types, but e.g. I know a programmer who never backed up his laptop (with important stuff) because he'd never had a hard drive go bad on him. You'll never guess what happened...

The hard part is getting 'normal' people to back up. It's really hard. They have all their data/documents on that laptop, and all the digital photographs from the first 18 months of their baby's life or whatever, but if you advise them to back up, you sound like some crazy lady who throws cats at people in the street.

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by diN0bot on Monday December 14, 2009 @06:36PM (#995427)
lots of people want to, but it can seem overwhelming. i'm quite technical as a programmer, but even i avoid IT muck whenever possible.

that's probably why companies such as dropbox are doing so well. making backups/restores easy is sweet.

(ps - thanks superduper! http://www.shirt-pocket.com/SuperDuper/SuperDuperDescription... "heroic system recovery for mere mortals")

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by access_denied on Monday December 14, 2009 @05:51PM (#995337)
[ ] Your normal people do use Mac OS X Leopare [X] Your normal people do not use Mac OS X Leopard

Time Machine is the solution: everyone gets it (at least the normal people I introduced it to).

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by oscardelben on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:32PM (#994547)
Also I see your business partner saying that the chance of a fire in the datacenter is so small that he should also worry about meteors at that point. I think that event is not that rare tough, just recall the last one in Seattle...
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by lucifer on Monday December 14, 2009 @09:04PM (#995647)
What's ironic (and somewhat irksome) is the preachy tone of your post.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by wglb on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:35PM (#994707)
Good blog post, particularly since it agrees with something I noted a little while ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=990903
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by mechanical_fish on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:08PM (#994485)
Unless I've missed further developments in the story, his business partner trusted the "backups" of the hosting company. Which did not properly restore.

So this is aimed one step farther up the chain.

Or, rather, it's aimed at all of us. It is a lesson that a lot of people need to learn.

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by andreyf on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:17PM (#994661)
Well, Jeff was asking his host "do you back up?", not "can you restore?". That's what the post is about. (Reading comprehension FTW!)
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by jseifer on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:10PM (#994489)
I think this was directed more at his business partners hosting company.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by gaius on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:11PM (#994495)
Who chose them and what due diligence was performed? This is business 101.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by mahmud on Monday December 14, 2009 @12:58PM (#994618)
Give me a break! (Hosting) companies will throw more references and specs at you than you know what to do with, and you have no choice but to take them for their word. The only thing you can do on your part is keep your own backups, independent of them.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by pyre on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:08PM (#994642)
> he only thing you can do on your part is keep your own backups, independent of them.

That's just common sense. What happens if your hosting company decides to be dicks about some billing dispute and holds your data hostage? Even the if hosting company-powered backups work, you're still hosed without your own backups.

Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by mahmud on Monday December 14, 2009 @02:09PM (#994788)
Exactly. Companies can say one thing and do another. My argument was against the accusative tone of "whoever did the due diligence".
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by axod on Monday December 14, 2009 @01:04PM (#994631)
Doing your own backups isn't rocket science. Why you would outsource such a valuable thing is beyond me.
Re:Let's Stop Talking About "Backups" by Periodic on Monday December 14, 2009 @03:02PM (#994946)
With backups being such a common thing, and something you probably could do but would rather not worry about, I don't see why you wouldn't outsource them.

Simple backups are easy. Understanding when something is sufficiently backed up and how to know whether it is backed up can be quite complex, particularly if large amounts of data is involved.

USB drives work great for a desktop with 1 TB, but not so well for 20TB. Then there is the question of how you know whether everything is sufficiently backed up, whether it is free from corruption, how you will move the backup data to a live server in the event of a restore.