However, the private market liquidity is always controlled by the company, and that can create artificial boundaries on timing and volume, which can be trouble if an employee wants to leave on their own schedule.
Also remember that if your $5mm company becomes a $1b unicorn after 4 years, and you got %0.5 at the start, then through dilution your %0.5 stake can become a %0.05 stake. Which means you get $500k / 4 years = $125k/yr in stock. But you cannot sell that stock, so it would of been better to go work at apple. It's very rare that a startup will pay better for an employee better than the big cos.
Yes, as I noted above I do agree that volume constraints are an issue and are pretty annoying. Even in the examples where you get to hold options for 7 years, you wouldn't get the ability to sell at the "peak" (if you think there is one) unless the company was public.
There are many things you have to take into account when valuing stock options, and from a purely compensation basis I agree that Apple/Google/Facebook are going to be tough to beat.
There was a good thread or subthread on this recently - can't find it.
The company has a large bag of tricks to dilute your options, if desired.
I had this discussion in depth with a Valley CEO a few years back. The best indicator you get as a candidate is that the CEO has rewarded employees in past exits.
Now focusing on the numbers could theoretically prove you're getting a bad deal, but it can never prove you're getting a good deal.
(I'm guessing the "hard questions" start with total shares/options outstanding, valuation, and liquidation preferences).
http://www.scribd.com/doc/55945011/An-Introduction-to-Stock-...
The "summary" section had a good list of questions, and if you read the document you'll have all the background necessary to understand their importance.
As an employee though, you can always vote with your feet. When considering a job at a startup, you should go over the stock option plan and ask hard questions. Remember... the founders (generally) don't have stock options. So sometimes founders at small startups don't even know the implications of the stock option plan they've created, and might be open to changing it if it means the difference between hiring you and not hiring you.
And for the larger companies that have thought about it, you can always pick the ones with more employee friendly plans. The higher the initial value of the company when joining, the harder it is to exercise options if you can't sell the stock immediately (because you have both a high exercise price and taxes on gains). So this can be a non-trivial difference between compensation offers at bigger companies.