That sounds very much like "hiring people based on having a reasonable conversation about their experience.” It is a perfectly sane and reasonable system, provided everyone involved is acting in good faith, has a great deal of ability to evaluate people based on their actual contribution to the success of the company, and nobody has any overt or internalized biases.
Without taking anything away from your company, I’m sure you will appreciate that in many companies, this business of “assigning you a bonus based on conversations with the project manager(s)” gets twisted into a horrible political game where people build fiefdoms based on tit-for-tat agreements, and where all sorts of biases come into play, e.g. the men are all “take-charge go-getters,” while the women are all “confrontational and bossy.”
I’m saying nothing about performance evaluations being better, just that results like you have experienced with your company are remarkably difficult to reproduce and sustain.
My bet is that if conversation works in your company, performance evaluations would also work. Maybe with more annoying paperwork involved, but it would still work.
It's important to first think of the active system at play and its influences on people, and second, try to improve it without disconnecting the model from reality.
This is a hard problem, and is one of the reasons leaders and managers need systems thinking skills above all.
[Citation needed]
Also, I find the version with paperwork better, because that creates a documentation trail. If someone is routinely favoring certain people or groups, documentation makes that easy to expose. As opposed to the "word of mouth" system where it's likely impossible.
Ability to understand your specific system and guide it is the far more important factor.
You ask for a citation for an opinion (see: "preferable") then proceed to share your own semi-claim without a citation.
Though probably not intended, saying "Citation Needed" can be off-putting and wastes time in discussions where if you spent a few extra seconds, you could ask a more thoughtful question. For example, your abridged quote has numerous elements and the target of your critique is unclear.
Lighten up!
> Both systems have their downsides. The simpler system generally has fewer...
I merely quoted the remainder to complete the sentence.
It appears simpler at first glance, because the complexity is deliberately hidden. The oft-quoted example concerns “structureless” organizations:
http://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm
This is not universal, but something to guard against: That the “simpler” system is not, in fact, a structureless environment where manipulative individuals will create an invisible complex system.
The Accenture news was raised on an internal discussion about the review process almost immediately, as some people are that keen to get rid of the current way of doing things ASAP. Sadly, I can't see anything coming from it, as the word is that Upper Management values the generated metrics too much to change anything.
I work in same type of company, and it's pretty obvious how this and similar corporate cr*p clearly doesn't bring the best out of people, sometimes in contrary. If I would be owner/shareholder of any company, ever, first thing I would be concerned how incentives/bonuses for that extra mile/good work are being given. The higher the management, the more bonuses would be tied to long term progress (i know it's easier written than done, but i consider it at least partly responsible for financial turmoil of recent years too).
Also, by forcing a relative appraisal of each employees performance, you force managers to view employees with a more critical eye. If I were to simply have to answer, "did X do a good job on this project?", my answer would almost always be yes, absent any incentive to say no. But there are members of my team who deliver significantly better than others, so the calibration process forces me to find a way to put them above the team members who perform at a lower level. Getting rid of performance reviews would, from what I've seen, create a culture of "don't screw up" rather than one of taking risks and trying to do as well as possible.
As a manager who both received an annual performance review and delivered 10 of them in the past week (our FY15 ends 7/31), I hate the process more than most people. But I think this discussion is ignoring the advantages just because we all hate the process. We run the risk of creating a whole new process that we hate just as much as the old process. Because it all boils down to finding an impartial way to evaluate performance and, unless you can crack that nut, your process isn't going to work. Top performers will move on and you'll be left with only under-performers. And that's because humans naturally evaluate their circumstances relatively rather than absolutely, once you get beyond the basics (i.e. can I pay rent and bills). Someone making $100k/yr is going to feel underpaid if someone they feel they're better than makes more. Just because the current system for ranking is flawed doesn't mean that there doesn't mean that ranking isn't necessary.
I can tell because I don't suck at my job. I look at pull requests. I look at ticket completion. I'm with my engineers during planning to know whether people are padding their estimates. I make a note whenever someone steps up in some way (handling emergencies off hours, helping another developer get their work done, etc.) If a manager doesn't understand the work of the people s/he's managing, that manager is unqualified to do the job.
As to your 1), it all depends on what type of culture a company has and how much employees are punished for screwing up. At a company like Facebook, you're expected to "move fast and break things." I'd be very surprised if people were inhibited there. If you're at a bank where screw ups mean someone gets fired, you're probably right.
I'm strongly skeptical that the review process that I've seen various company is any good at helping to make the real connections between employee performance and company bottom lines. In the end, the ranking process of doling out salaries is fooling itself by cloaking the process in numbers.
Instead we all have to be identical, and our "development plan" is all about getting better at doing things that normally I'd let somebody else take care of, because they will always be better at it than I am. No big raise for me, even though I've saved you two headcount and reduced regressions by a factor of four by improving the dev process and toolchain.
Oh, you're surprised I gave my two weeks?
Then the place got engulfed by this insane fad for "performance reviews", which is idiotic on its face for a number of reasons:
1. You request review feedback from peers - this is unworkable because if you work with someone who is useless, and you say so in their review, your working relationship with them becomes untenable;
2. The process also requires "self review", which is nothing but a mechanism for bullshitters to big themselves up. It is also time-consuming, and good people are generally too busy to dedicate much time to it; the bullshitters and timewasters otoh will happily dedicate days to polishing their lies and exaggerations;
3. In general the process massively favours those who play the performance review system, i.e. the politicians;
4. You are required to set "career objectives", which is almost entirely pointless since as a tech person you are largely constrained by what jobs need your skills at the particular moment you become available; there is little tolerance for people sitting around idle waiting for the perfect role that meets their desired objective.