That's really an excellent point! Thanks.
Using renewables or nuclear power to extract fossil fuels amounts to something almost like indirect energy conversion/storage. It can also work between fossil sources. I've heard the tar sands described as a massive indirect gas liquefaction plant -- it's economical because direct GTL is less efficient than gas -> steam -> bitumen -> liquids.
Apparently the largest solar installation in the world is used to generate steam that is used to extract oil. I can imagine (just about) a strange future with a renewable powered oil industry, because oil has certain benefits that electricity doesn't (use as airplane fuel for example). Such fuel would have a lower carbon impact overall, though probably only slightly lower.
I think it makes sense that at some point we'll start leaving oil in the ground, but not sure if that's because its price will keep going up, or if its replacements will keep getting cheaper/better, and what affect that has on oil prices.