More strongly the author is trying to argue that its an easy fallacy to get drawn into psychological motives because we're "great" at modeling other people's thoughts. In light of this implicitly perceived strength we tend to ignore the real likelihood of the evidences.
I don't know if it's something I agree about, however. I haven't personally reviewed the evidence and don't particularly put a lot of trust in any of the sources including the Less Wrong contributors.
See also: the experimental portion of this essay http://lesswrong.com/lw/1j7/the_amanda_knox_test_how_an_hour...
(a) It isn't zero-sum. Guede was convicted -- he is guilty, he did it. What we are determining is whether he acted alone.
(b) The priors are crap because they are weak, not because they are agreed upon. This is just a model, and it feels to me that the author is overfitting. The prior you mentioned as an example is so far away from the case at hand to be virtually useless.
In the article actual physical evidence is dismissed because it's "small in quantity". The amount of blood is far less important than whose blood it is. You only need a little dna to prove contact. And you only need a little blood to prove prescence at the scene of an injury. It sounds to me like the jury was doing it's job and the article's author was just looking for a point to make.
To put this another way, have a think about where you would expect your own DNA to show up. At home, at your partner's appartment, at the office, at the cafe around the corner from the office, in your car, in your partner's car, at your best friend's home, your best friend's car. If a murder ever took place in one of these locations, how would you feel about the presence of your DNA being used to implicate you in the murder?
But I strongly disagree on your understanding of the impact of priors. There are several ways to look at it, all equivalent. The easiest is the single prior: Did she do it? None of us are psychic, so that isn't helpful, 'cause we cant estimate it at all. We have to break that down into some of its components.
In fact, your argument (which I totally agree with, BTW) is based on a very specific prior: that in cases with this kind of relative imbalance of evidence, there is a high prob that one party is guilty and the other isn't (or some such, I may not be stating it as specifically as I should be).
All the evidence presented has it's own implied priors, and the right combination of evidence has it's own prior, etc. These all need to be combined with weights based on other priors. Since noone can compute all of these priors in the space of one hour, that makes it all a judgment call, not a rational decision.
And this is where I think the post's pontificating gets it terribly wrong. There's nothing rational at all about the process, other than you're attempting to blindly apply the Bayesian formula.
I do think your definition of a prior is a bit off though... like, the choices around priors wouldn't be whether to use "did she do it" vs the imbalances of evidence or such. We're trying to estimate the likelihood of "did she do it," so the question is what do we use to do that? The prior probability of "she did it" has to be the probability that some random member of the 20/female/american/student general public will commit the murder, because we don't have anything more than that (as you said). Then, we update our estimate by looking at the available evidence (such as, "was found standing by door holding bleach mop," which would the viewed in terms of the likelihood that that would be observed and the statement 'she did not do it' being true) to come to our posterior probability, which is the estimate informed by all of the available evidence.
As a side note, it's great when you can have a civil discussion on the internet. Maybe there's hope for HN after all.
The comments on the post relate further evidence that was missing from the analysis the poster provides. Why? Because the poster made a judgement call that it wasn't relevant. That alone makes this just so much blathering... sorry.
There is a reasonable doubt.
What evidence is missing from the internet that makes them guilty? I guess we will find out in a few months when the judge and jury issue their written explanation.
Is anyone willing to state that they are certain Knox and Solecito are guilty of murder?