News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by joosters on Thursday July 23, 2015 @11:43AM (#9936442)
But are the security experts actually safer online?

The study seems to assume that they are. It may be a fair assumption, but it would be interesting to know if it actually is true or not. It would also help validate the security practices.

If it turns out that the security experts got infected just as much, or only slightly less than the non-experts, then following their practices might not be worth the effort...

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by Florin_Andrei on Thursday July 23, 2015 @02:57PM (#9937759)
> But are the security experts actually safer online?

s/security experts/technical users/

Yes, we are. Whenever you see a laptop full of malware, that's a non-technical user. We're not safe from it entirely, nobody is 100% safe, but we're in much better shape than the regular folks.

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by joosters on Thursday July 23, 2015 @03:42PM (#9937996)
Citation needed!

Not just being pedantic here for the sake of it, I think it would be good to know how much safer experts generally are. Just saying "we're better than them!" isn't very convincing or useful.

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by scintill76 on Thursday July 23, 2015 @08:33PM (#9939378)
I'm skeptical too. "The experts", e.g. HBGary, get pwned worse than having a bunch of crapware on their desktop, but it's for the same types of mistakes:

"So what do we have in total? A Web application with SQL injection flaws and insecure passwords. Passwords that were badly chosen. Passwords that were reused. Servers that allowed password-based authentication. Systems that weren't patched. And an astonishing willingness to hand out credentials over e-mail, even when the person being asked for them should have realized something was up. [...]

Most frustrating for HBGary must be the knowledge that they know what they did wrong, and they were perfectly aware of best practices; they just didn't actually use them. Everybody knows you don't use easy-to-crack passwords, but some employees did. Everybody knows you don't re-use passwords, but some of them did. Everybody knows that you should patch servers to keep them free of known security flaws, but they didn't." [1]

Granted, this doesn't prove that experts are generally unsafe, and maybe somebody with a beef with these ones in particular would say they're just semi-knowledgeable salesmen cashing in on the cyber scare, but it lends some weight to the idea that too many experts aren't much safer.

[1] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/02/anonymous-speaks-...

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by pixl97 on Thursday July 23, 2015 @09:07PM (#9939512)
Experts in what?

Where I work the actual IT staff/server admins are pretty safe. They update, patch, and in general choose good passwords.

The programmers... ugh, good lord. They have the worst practices ever.

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by scintill76 on Friday July 24, 2015 @03:13AM (#9940503)
Well, my example of HBGary was chosen because they were a firm specializing in computer security. But, as shown by Ars Technica (or claimed by Anonymous) they had some pretty bad security failures themselves.

You do have a point about programmers, or to generalize a bit, people who are more technically-inclined than average but who don't care/know about security. I shake my head seeing things like people flashing community-built Android ROMs with signature checks disabled, closed-source rooting tools, sideloaded APKs downloaded from dubious filesharing sites, "curl http://whatever | sh".

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by lucb1e on Thursday July 23, 2015 @01:16PM (#9937134)
Very good question, but I'm not sure how you imagine this could be addressed.

Security experts may use a lot more password managers and want to use unique passwords, but you could say that's just because they have a lot more accounts than normal people. Most people have a couple accounts for social networking, their bank, perhaps a local library... experts usually work in the field, spend their days online in an office, and have lots of accounts for various tasks or activities.

The attack surface is very different: lots of accounts versus just a couple. Lots of time online browsing various sites versus browsing your average social network in spare time. Perhaps I'm overgeneralizing, but it probably matches a good percentage.

And then there is the definition of "safer" or "expert". Are you an expert when you got a degree in the field? When you followed some online courses? When you work in the field? Or when you read a lot about security?

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by joosters on Thursday July 23, 2015 @01:41PM (#9937289)
The paper acknowledges the problem in defining a security expert (see 5.1: Limitations)

Defining a security “expert” is challenging, and we settled upon a definition that is simple (5+ self-reported years of experience in the area)

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by lallysingh on Thursday July 23, 2015 @03:19PM (#9937877)
I don't think that you can correlate number of accounts vs security awareness of the user.

Some users may be social butterflies, and some may be hermits. Independent of their level-of-security-awareness.

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by iulia_ion on Saturday July 25, 2015 @12:29AM (#9946549)
The truth is that we don't know if security experts are actually safer. Maybe the fact that they are experts makes them more confident that they can deal with an incident if such a thing arises. So it might be that they take more risks, but then are simply better at fixing things when they break.

We also don't have a ground truth for what users should do to stay safe online. Do updates work better than a strong password? Measuring the effectiveness of different security actions as scale is so challenging, that we don't now how to do it.

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by TempaTaccount on Thursday July 23, 2015 @11:57AM (#9936560)
Are the security experts are target more likely to attract those who might want to compromise them for bragging rights?
Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by joosters on Thursday July 23, 2015 @12:18PM (#9936713)
Yes, plus it might be true that security experts visit riskier websites because of the nature of their research. It's a difficult task to try and balance these factors out to make a useful comparison.
Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by theseatoms on Thursday July 23, 2015 @11:53AM (#9936525)
If they aren't safer online, that'd be a sign to me that I shouldn't bother trying to do everything right.

I don't want invest the time and energy developing expertise when even those that have it don't use it.

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by dublinben on Thursday July 23, 2015 @12:05PM (#9936623)
It depends on what your definition of safety is. The perspective of this paper probably relates to compromised accounts and information leaks, not adware infections.
Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by joosters on Thursday July 23, 2015 @12:25PM (#9936764)
I haven't completely read the full paper yet (it's pretty big), but in a brief scan, I can't actually find any definition they use for staying safe. They talk about 'protecting their security online' and 'to stay safe online', however I didn't spot anything more specific.

As you point out, there are a variety of attacks and big differences between e.g. leaking a password or getting a virus infection. But since their highlighted techniques cover both of these attacks (virus scanners, password best practices), you have to assume that they are relating to a whole range of attacks.

Re:Comparing how security experts and non-experts stay safe ... by iulia_ion on Saturday July 25, 2015 @12:32AM (#9946554)
We did not provide a definition of what "staying safe online" means. As a result, some participants might have thought more of protecting online accounts, while others focussed on keeping their systems from getting compromised, etc. But coming from a non-technical user the question would be likely to be framed just like that: vague, because users don't know what the biggest threats are and what they should defend from first.