News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by danieltillett on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @03:32AM (#9928181)
"Personally, I doubt that the world is ready for this," said Stephen Gardiner, a University of Washington philosophy professor who studies the ethics of environmental policies. "Geoengineering raises huge ethical and political questions, nationally and internationally.”

Am I the only one sick of self-appointed ethicists opposing everything. I have yet to read a quote where one said something is good and should be done - I can see them saying “Clean drinking water: Personally, I doubt that the world is ready for this”.

Edit. These guys are trying to develop an insurance policy for us if it turns out climate change is worse than expected.

The scientists say there will be deep satisfaction if their project succeeds, but far better would be a future without global warming.

"We would be perfectly happy," Cooper said, "if our method works beautifully -- and it never needs to be used.”

Rather than support this the ethicists have to oppose even having an alternative option. Much better to just do nothing and let the planet burn down - at least the world will be ready for that.

Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by hmlty-rqd on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @10:26AM (#9929804)
I'm more sick of arrogant engineering types who continuously belittle anyone outside their own limited bubble.

Firstly, he's not a 'self-appointed ethicist', he's a professor appointed by the University of Washington. And your ridiculous straw man about drinking water is not appropriate and serves merely to reflect badly on you.

Secondly, he's not 'opposing everything'. He states, quite correctly, that there are large ethical and political implications to any significant form of geoengineering. We regularly see examples of this. For instance, when a major river passes through multiple countries and an upstream country decides to build a dam, reducing or eliminating the flow of the river downstream, potentially affecting hundreds of millions of people. That this has huge ethical and political implications is unquestionable.

Similarly, if an entity such as a government or corporation decides to unilaterally modify the climate, this too has ethical and political implications. Even if the actual outcome closely matches what was predicted, such changes may be unwanted by other parties. Furthermore, there could be knock-on effects from changes in one location to elsewhere. For example, suppose the United States engages in climate modification by purposefully increasing rainfall in the south-west US. This may be welcome there, but could have the side-effect of increasing drought elsewhere.

I don't see any ethicists opposing geoengineering in principle, they're just pushing for a full debate - which would include many more aspects than just the engineering one.

Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by danieltillett on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @05:33PM (#9932456)
>Firstly, he's not a 'self-appointed ethicist', he's a professor appointed by the University of Washington.

Yes he is - all “ethicists” are self-appointed. The particular self-appointed ethicist in this article is actually a philosophy professor. I can call myself an ethicist too if I want to - ironically I can’t call myself an engineer.

>I don't see any ethicists opposing geoengineering in principle, they're just pushing for a full debate - which would include many more aspects than just the engineering one.

Can you actually find one? I have read dozens of posts and papers from these self-appointed ethicists and I have never come across one that supports anything new. They never raise any real reasons to oppose anything new, they just oppose the new because it is new.

There is no point having a “debate” about geoengineering unless we actual do some research first to know if it is possible.

Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by Osmium on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @07:45AM (#9928974)
> "Geoengineering raises huge ethical and political questions, nationally and internationally."

This is true though. We have some treaties[1][2], but not enough, and it still needs to be thought through.

What happens if, say, country A is being badly affected by climate change, and they have the means to pump tonnes of SO2 into the atmosphere? They think it'd help with global warming, but country B doesn't and think it could make the climate worse? Who gets to decide? Do A and B then go to war over this?

No disagreement at all that the research should be done, but it raises huge ethical and political questions, and there's nothing wrong with acknowledging that. When it comes to technologies that could change an entire planet's climate, opposition as the default position seems entirely reasonable.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_Modification_Con...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_on_Biological_Diver...

Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by danieltillett on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @08:36AM (#9929196)
Geoengineering is really no different than any other international issue. Ultimately countries need to agree or go to war as a last resort.

None of the scientists in the article are talking about implementing geoengineering - they just want us to do the research so we have options if the worst of the worst happens. In my opinion it is always better to have options when faced with a bad situation rather than none especially if the reason you have no options is because you refused to plan.

Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by InclinedPlane on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @06:35AM (#9928738)
There's an underlying element here. Some people have developed a sort of belief system around the idea of carbon emissions being intrinsically amoral. For them, man-made CO2 emissions are dirty, gross, and fundamentally sinful. Ameliorating the impact of CO2 on the climate is thus something like purchasing a religious indulgence in that worldview. Anything that enables continued carbon emissions without humanity suffering the consequences is thus seen as extremely morally suspect.
Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by danieltillett on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @07:02AM (#9928830)
Yes there is a bit of this (the beaver's dam is good and part of nature while the human dam is bad), but the previous thinking was more if we as scientists provide alternatives then the politicians will decide they don't need to do anything about emissions. There has been a bit of an epiphany within the scientific community of late that we might have left it too late to solve just by reducing emissions and that we also need to work on alternatives just in case.
Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by mangeletti on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @08:22AM (#9929134)
I think there is something intuitively different between the engineering of non-human animals in nature[1] that has gone on for millions of years and which the rest of nature has evolved along side of, and the human engineering[2] that has drastically changed the face of the planet in less than 200 years, rendering much of nature extinct in the meantime.

1. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/4c/American...

2. http://news.xinhuanet.com/english2010/china/2010-07/20/13406...

Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by danieltillett on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @08:28AM (#9929160)
The difference is we (humans) are better at engineering than beavers (not a put down of beavers as they are amazing).
Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by adaml_623 on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @07:28AM (#9928928)
Can you give some links for the epiphany you mention. I'm interested in geoengineering
Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by danieltillett on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @08:41AM (#9929226)
I will try and dig out some of the good papers I have tomorrow (it is getting later here), but a good place to start is wiki [1]. Have a read through all the references they have.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_engineering

Re:Cloud brightening experiment tests tool to slow climate c... by 7952 on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @08:31AM (#9929171)
And by focussing on the big bad we ignore the more immediate threats that fossil fuel burning causes. The health issues caused by vehicle emissions are well documented yet there is little social pressure against buying dirty cars (which are much more obviously sinful).