Re:Hackers Remotely Attack a Jeep on the Highway
by yellowapple on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @09:36PM
(#9927197)
> With respect to letting the driver in on it, it's pretty clear they withheld most information:
The reporter knew there were going to be attacks in the first place. There was also plenty of reason to believe said attacks could severely impair safety.
> Oh look, another false dilemma.
It's a trilemma; the concept of "do the test 'responsibly'" was already implied, so I merely provided the other outcomes. There's "perfect execution of demonstration" and "no demonstration"; between that is a spectrum of perfection, on which this demonstration happens to lie somewhere near the lower-middle.
I don't disagree that the demo could've been done with more safety precautions, but the desire to do a "live" demonstration like this seems pretty reasonable, and even a demonstration lower on the perfection spectrum is preferable to the bottom end of "nothing at all".
The reporter knew there were going to be attacks in the first place. There was also plenty of reason to believe said attacks could severely impair safety.
> Oh look, another false dilemma.
It's a trilemma; the concept of "do the test 'responsibly'" was already implied, so I merely provided the other outcomes. There's "perfect execution of demonstration" and "no demonstration"; between that is a spectrum of perfection, on which this demonstration happens to lie somewhere near the lower-middle.
I don't disagree that the demo could've been done with more safety precautions, but the desire to do a "live" demonstration like this seems pretty reasonable, and even a demonstration lower on the perfection spectrum is preferable to the bottom end of "nothing at all".