Re:Help save MySQL
by davidw on Sunday December 13, 2009 @03:15AM
(#992555)
The Cynic: he certainly wasn't raising this big a stink when he was selling Mysql off to Sun for a great deal of money.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I felt irritated enough about this to write about it:
http://journal.dedasys.com/2009/12/13/mysql-oracle-and-the-e...
Extremely clear, thought out, and well written.
Good job sir.
You know, I never really understood the fuss because well you can just fork the freaking thing. But what you cover in your analysis that you link to, I never though of it that way. It is kind of "Pricky" to sell the thing no conditions to Sun and then when you are not a party to the secondary transaction, do a bunch of hand-waving.
Very good, really. I am tweeting a link to it right now.
Another contrarian view: if Oracle does do to MySQL what Monty warns about this may accelerate interest in GPLed forks, e.g. Drizzle. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drizzle_%28database_server%29
And just to make that even more obvious, that would be a good thing.
The difference, and he spells it out quite clearly, is that Oracle already has a database and that it wants to sell its database and that MySQL interferes with that.
But as soon as you've sold something, isn't it up to the new owner to decide what to do with whatever it is you've sold?
Re:Help save MySQL
by nostrademons on Sunday December 13, 2009 @04:19PM
(#993120)
Legally, yeah. But many startup founders consider carefully what the new owner is going to do with their creation before selling it. That's the responsible thing to do, because there're users who don't have a legal say in the transaction, but will often be impacted quite severely if the new owner buys a product to kill it.
Look at the outcry when the Etherpads sold their company to Google so it could be killed, for example.
Selling to Sun would not seem to me to be a move directed by such careful consideration.
Hindsight is 20-20, of course, but still - I don't remember thinking of it as a good move for the future of MySQL at the time.
And thus creating a monopoly in the database market? No. There is plenty of competition, both open source and proprietary.
Of course there is. But Oracle may feel it makes no sense to compete against itself.