I like it in principle, but I don't feel like it's a good solution in practice, at least until we get some cases going before a judge to see how it gets interpreted.
This is ridiculous i encourage you to remember the state of affaires before gpl. User freedom wasn't even on the map. It changed everything and overall the users gained a lot. Also you should remember that gpl freedom is an ethical question. And as allways if there is an infection the medicine could make the parasites react against it.
Before the GPL, the biggest software companies hiring the highest paid developers were companies that made proprietary software that ran on a users machine and the data did not leave the user's machine.
Now the biggest tech companies are companies that use GPL software to run infrastructure that gives users 'free' services and in exchange takes their data and sells it. Because they are using it as a web, they can keep all their secrets.
Now you tell me, what scenario is more conducive to user freedom and privacy.
If you look at who is actually paid to work on GPL software, I would guess that most people either work for hardware companies or companies whose revenue is from advertisers. Relatively few are working on software that is actually for end-users to run on their own personal computer.
GPL is great if you are Stallman and limit yourself to only what you can build yourself. For the average user, they are less free, more beholden to a platform, and have less control of their data than in the pre-GPL era.
Next, the AGPL is and will be a very small percentage of GPL licensed software.
Finally, apart from making a political statement, I do not see the AGPL getting any traction. Apart from MongoDB (which has its drivers as Apache) I cannot think of any widely used software that is AGPL.
Also, note that while MongoDB is AGPL, if you look at the contributor license (https://www.mongodb.com/legal/contributor-agreement) any contributor is giving MongoDB the right to use and license your contribution and to make derivative works of which they are the sole owner. They can also license your code under a non-copyleft license to others. I do not see how in this case a (A)GPL is more free than a BSD/MIT license. Along this line, you will see that many successfull GPL projects (excepting Linux and the FSF ones) are of this type where the source code is GPL but any contributions give some type of copyright assignment to the company which then sells basically closed-source licenses to corporations who don't want the GPL.
edit: Rewrote first point.
The difference in user freedom between web apps and client apps is much bigger than the difference between a GPL client app and a proprietary client app. With a client app, even a proprietary one - the user at least in theory can see exactly what the application is doing and what data it is transmitting where.
So for the average user - GPL has encouraged loss of user freedom. Of course this doesn't affect Stallman because he does not use any web apps.