News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by lmm on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @10:50AM (#9922617)
It is as real a particle as any other, no? If you look closely enough all particles are just waveforms in particular fields (e.g. an electron will "interfere with itself" in a double-slit experiment).
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by gus_massa on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @07:51PM (#9926752)
It' more complicated. The electrons are waves in a quantized field, so the math is more complicated. When you try to simplify the math, with some simplifications you get something that looks like a classical particle and with other simplifications you get something that looks like a classical wave. So in some experiments you get electrons that behave like a particle and in some experiments you get electrons that behave like a wave.

Anyway, it's difficult to say what a real particle is. The easiest example is the Z0 particle, because you can think it is a mix of the W0 particles with the B0 particles, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W_and_Z_bosons#Z_bosons

Anyway, if we "agree" that a real particle is something that can travel in vacuum, then the electrons are real and the particles in this experiment are not real. But if you talk with the people in solid state physics, they are totally convinced that phonons are real particles in spite they can travel only inside a solid.

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by Zuider on Thursday July 23, 2015 @03:36PM (#9937966)
But from the point of view of a phonon, the solid is indistinguishable from a vacuum. What distinguishes the 'real' vacuum from what the phonon sees?

Why is what we call 'the universe' necessarily primal? Maybe it is 'vibrating solids' all the way down. If there is something primal, then what are its characteristics that allows what we see as the vacuum to emerge?

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by fsloth on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @12:58PM (#9923744)
I suppose the word 'real' is kinda hard here. From classical experimental point of view electron is a particle that can be observed and has an identity and existence regardless of context, whereas quasiparticles such as phonons manifest only in mathematical models that 'can be instantiated' in specific experimental setup, or describe physics only in specific limited context, such as the experiment here.

I'm of the school though that adheres to the notion that maths can be used to model the world, and while it strongly suggests 'the world is made of math' this is not conclusively the case. So, to me, mathematical equivalence does not mean 'physically equal' since physical systems can exhibit many more degrees of freedom than just those captured in a specific model. Sometimes the maths and physics match astoundingly well.

Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by losername on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:17PM (#9924471)
Don't phonons manifest in sound, which is very audible?
Re:Massless particle with promise for next-generation electr... by fsloth on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:35PM (#9925104)
Only in lattices I think - i.e. a specific substrate such as crystals:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phonon