Re:Daniel Kahneman: ‘What would I eliminate if I had a magic...
by eivarv on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @09:41AM
(#9922152)
Credentials can certainly be a good guideline, but as I'm sure you know HIV- and AIDS-researchers don't make the argument that their claims are true because of their authority status (which would be an appeal to authority), but because of the research their claims are based upon - as opposed to Jenny McCarthy et al.
Outside of high school debate clubs, it's pretty reasonable to consider the demonstrated expertise of people making claims. I tend to take the opinion of medical researchers about the relationship of HIV and AIDS over the opinions of members of the Foo Fighters and Thabo Mbeki, for example.
The opinion of an expert, in his area of expertise, backed by a career's worth of research, seems a little more likely to be correct than a random on the internet backed by nothing more that "nuh-uh!"