Re:SpaceX CRS-7 Failure Investigation Teleconference Thread
by XorNot on Monday July 20, 2015 @11:33PM
(#9920439)
Are SpaceX famous for COTS though? My impression was that they manufacture a ridiculous amount of stuff in-house for ... well pretty much this exact reason.
I'd argue that the likely result here is Elon Musk will continue his campaign of "hell with it, we'll build our own".
Re:SpaceX CRS-7 Failure Investigation Teleconference Thread
by lutorm on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @03:50PM
(#9925241)
They are famous for going for COTS in order to save money.
On the contrary, SpaceX is famous for vertical integration. COTS may have been the idea back in the Falcon 1 days, but those days are long gone.
I suspect SpaceX's costs are going to, over time, increase significantly as they continue to learn that playing it loose isn't always possible in that business. They are famous for going for COTS in order to save money.
This is NOT a put-down. I think what they are doing is fantastic. It is obviously redefining aerospace. At the same time I am astounded that critical structural components are not 100% tested. That said, metalurgy isn't my area of expertise, which means my opinion here could be complete nonsense. Perhaps this particular failure mode can only be tested through destructive methods (sectioning?) which means you can never be 100% certain to be flying good metal.