Re:Call9 (YC S15) Delivers On-Demand Doctors in Emergency Si...
by brandonb on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:00PM
(#9919043)
FWIW, Washington state is exceptionally good at treating cardiac arrest. See table 4 here:
http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=182614
SCA survival rate of 16% in Seattle, vs. 3% in Alabama or 5.5% in Toronto.
Still a long ways to go, even for the best regions.
Re:Call9 (YC S15) Delivers On-Demand Doctors in Emergency Si...
by FireBeyond on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:04PM
(#9919065)
Very true. As objectively as possible, I realize we're at the 'leading edge', and there are a lot of improvements, both here and elsewhere, to be made.
But then again, I'm sure Call9 would rather be compared to 'how we fare versus the best EMS systems in the country, not the worst'. :)
Re:Call9 (YC S15) Delivers On-Demand Doctors in Emergency Si...
by comrh on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:51PM
(#9919359)
Toronto is more than 4x the population of Seattle and 2x the area though. And Alabama is a often rural state. It would be interesting to compare survival rates based on equal distances to a hospital.
Depending on the location, when you dispatch ALS/BLS ambulances this way, whose medical license are the EMTs and paramedics working under? Does the county medical protocol director like/want this?
In cases of cardiac arrest, you're going to typically want more than an EMT and a medic on an ambulance. CPR is, as you know, a man-power intensive activity.
The three things you mention are not really problems in a 'modern' PSAP. "911, what are you reporting?" "Confirmed cardiac arrest". Even without that, in most areas around here criteria-based dispatch is used to determine ALS/BLS with an erring towards ALS if there's any question.
In my county (Washington state), the protocol states (and is met with 94% reliability that from call reception for EMS, dispatchers should have toned the appropriate unit(s) with 60 seconds of call reception, and those units should be en route within 2 minutes of that (even for in quarters response).