Statistics cant prove anything! Thats his point. Dont be so confident that your mind is too closed to explore other possibilities.
Scientific method can only eliminate possibilities and show you the most probable option. It is by no means proof. But thats a bad reason to not consider competing hypothesis instead of just trying to confirm an existing bias.
Your point about incubator success is different. Those statistics are exactly the ones we want to avoid. Success or failure of a startup in an incubator is not diagnostic evidence as i can think of a dozen other hypothesis to explain those results. Its like a doctor saying you have strep because you have fever. Since fever is consistent with other diagnosis it has no diagnostic value beyond the point of saying you are sick.
And in fact, I agree with that rationale. I still can't believe I went through with it, much less succeeded.
But without foolhardy people to take on these gigantic risks, we'd be FAR less developed than we are.