Re:Welcome to Hacker News
by krapp on Monday July 20, 2015 @11:50AM
(#9916829)
Which does more damage to the community, brief thank you comments or the tangential discussions that inevitably break out around them, when a single such comment is downvoted then the downvote is explained?
I think some allowance needs to be made for the fact that most comments lack much substance or insight, since most commenters are having conversations with one another, not engaging in formal debate or rhetoric. I personally suspect the threaded nature of the forums encourages this behavior, whether pg intended it to or not.
Perhaps a word limit could be added to the comments, but guaranteeing comments are more verbose doesn't really guarantee higher intellectual quality. If the noise caused by short comments is an issue then perhaps /newcomments could be filtered so that it only displays replies to the root post (which are most likely to be focused on the subject at hand) or doesn't display very short comments.
Given the assumption the site makes by increasing the posting timeout in deep threads (which i've come to grudgingly agree with) that incivility tends to increase the more deeply into a thread you go, this might also reduce the visibility of and engagement with toxic comments.
I think some allowance needs to be made for the fact that most comments lack much substance or insight, since most commenters are having conversations with one another, not engaging in formal debate or rhetoric. I personally suspect the threaded nature of the forums encourages this behavior, whether pg intended it to or not.
Perhaps a word limit could be added to the comments, but guaranteeing comments are more verbose doesn't really guarantee higher intellectual quality. If the noise caused by short comments is an issue then perhaps /newcomments could be filtered so that it only displays replies to the root post (which are most likely to be focused on the subject at hand) or doesn't display very short comments.
Given the assumption the site makes by increasing the posting timeout in deep threads (which i've come to grudgingly agree with) that incivility tends to increase the more deeply into a thread you go, this might also reduce the visibility of and engagement with toxic comments.