News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by jessriedel on Monday July 20, 2015 @11:42AM (#9916756)
All parties involved can be at fault. And lots of people will think that privacy, while very important, is not quite at the same level as marital fidelity.

It's like hearing that a vicious murderous mob boss had his leg shot off. Yes, the person who took his leg ought to be sent to jail, but we might not have much sympathy for the mob boss since his terrible actions led directly to those consequences.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by john_b on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:19PM (#9917490)
Except that shooting someone is generally illegal, whereas having an affair is not. Allocate your sympathy as you wish, but don't pretend that a person deserves to be the victim of a crime because you or anyone else find their behavior distasteful.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by josinalvo on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:49PM (#9917737)
To cheat, to break your word given to a life partner, is not just distasteful. It is wrong. It makes the world a darker place, and not only to you and your partner (and that is what wrong means)

I know this kind of statement is viewed with distrust. And I see why this is so. But I think some moral discussion might be good (rather than just the bland 'lets not judge')

First, I am not saying that I think all marriages need to be monogamical or 'till death'. Both ideas are probably bad on average (i.e.: make the world a darker place as well, cause needless suffering). I, for one, think that promissing monogamy is a bad idea.

But to break the promice of monogamy is, indeed, bad. First, it is inherently unfair: One partner (Pa) might be resisting temptations, to the benefit of the other (Pb). Pb gets benefits from increased marriage security, increase sexual availability from Pa, increased emotional availability... But does not offer the same.

I mean, it would be clear that withdrawing all the money from a joint savings account is bad, right? That is the same thing... One side is doing a lot of effort to keep a mutual benefit working...

To cheat is a form of exploitation.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by fnordfnordfnord on Monday July 20, 2015 @02:20PM (#9917940)
The time, place, and manner of sex or other activity that occurs between two consenting adults is none of my business whatsoever unless one of those people is my spouse. When one of those people is my spouse and the other is not me, then my problem is with my spouse, not with any website or other instrument used to facilitate the infidelity. What meaning would an agreement such as marriage have if cheating were literally impossible?

>But I think some moral discussion might be good

Let's discuss how we can keep from inflicting our own personal morals on those who do not share our moral philosophies; lest someone show up here and one-up us all with an even better morality than the one we already have.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by josinalvo on Monday July 20, 2015 @04:19PM (#9918749)
>Let's discuss how we can keep from inflicting our own personal morals on those who do not share our moral philosophies

The interesting question, is, of course, which are private matters and which are matters of injustice that 'society' should intervene to fix.

THE WHOLE QUESTION is whether or not cheating is 'a private matter' or 'an injustice that ...'. Just stating that it is 'private' does not seem to be an answer to the question. If I understood you correctly, your argument it 'is is private, leave it alone, else someone else will mess with other private issues'. Why do you think it belongs to the 'private' rather than 'injustice' category?

> one-up us all with an even better morality than the one we already have.

For me, that would be very nice indeed! Convincing moral arguments are very rare!

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by fnordfnordfnord on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:37PM (#9919274)
I think I was quite clear as to why a marital relationship is a private matter.

I think we can agree that in society there are many different moral systems. Now I will use the words "good" and "bad" with the stipulation that these words have no inherent meaning, but instead only have the meaning that we apply to them from within our own personal moral system. You can compare another moral system to your own, and decide that it is "better" or "worse" but you cannot make an objective determination. Now, you can decide that your morality where adultery should be prohibited/prevented/punished is better for your purposes than mine where adultery is none of the government's business, but that is just your personal preference. The problem is that this may never end and there is always another fellow who is more moral than you or I or both of us, and whose morality tells him that shoes are immoral or that red-haired people are witches or something like that; and this fellow wants the government to segregate the witches for the protection of the good moral folks, and also prevent everyone from wearing shoes, even firemen. So, we have to compromise on our morality and find a set of common rules upon which most of us can agree and which will protect people from serious harm even if it allows for some behavior that makes some of us uncomfortable.

Why do you think that two other peoples' marriage is some concern to you, or to society at large? And please, no references to vague concepts that we have no real definition of such as 'making the world a darker place'

>For me, that would be very nice indeed! Convincing moral arguments are very rare!

That's because morals are very personal, arbitrary, and often irrational.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by josinalvo on Monday July 20, 2015 @11:23PM (#9920409)
Thank you for your reply.

No, I am not harmed when two people (Pa and Pb) are married, and Pa cheats on Pb. The reason I'd oppose AM is because it normalizes and helps the harmful behaviour of Pa towards Pb. I am quite sure that there is some marginal contribution of AM to the number of cheatings and broken marriages. I think we can objectively say that AM contributes to needless suffering. Do you agree?

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:47PM (#9925689)
We can agree that act(s) of marital infidelity cause people to suffer. Sites such as AM are not my favorite thing, but it is simply not my place or yours to tell other people how to manage their personal lives. I do not think that the existence of AM causes anyone to think that infidelity is okay who did not previously think that was the case, therefore, AM is not contributing to the moral decay of society. I'm not going to transfer the blame to the third party. AM did not force anyone to participate. There would still be marital infidelity if AM did not exist, and as you say, I expect their contribution to be marginal.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by cjsthompson on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:40PM (#9919286)
Let's discuss how we are forced to live with people who don't share our standards of behavior (like those who cling to 17th century individualistic philosophy which science has long debunked) and force us to compromise on the kind of society we want because of centralized government.

Let's also discuss how human behavioral biology predicts that if you are in favor of polygamy you are highly likely to be an arrogant, aggressive, sexist bully (like males of tournament species are) who makes society worse for everyone else.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by fnordfnordfnord on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:23PM (#9919509)
In another reply in this subthread, I explain my ideas about compromise based upon what I learned in elementary school. It may make me slightly uncomfortable to share the land with flat-earthers, but as long as they don't try to teach astronomy to my children I'll leave them be. I might even have them over for dinner or mow their lawn when they're away since, aside from being morons who don't vote the same as me, they are mostly pleasant, generous, peaceful people.

>Let's also discuss how human behavioral biology predicts that if you are in favor of polygamy you are highly likely to be an arrogant, aggressive, sexist bully (like males of tournament species are) who makes society worse for everyone else.

Okay, can we talk about how to best implement a eugenics program to help us solve this problem too? Or perhaps compulsory psychiatric medication? Compulsory hormone therapy?

I think the majority of people agree that polygamy is verboten, not that I really care in principle, at least as far as the law goes. What poly-amorous folks do with each other is none of my business.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by cjsthompson on Monday July 20, 2015 @09:46PM (#9920164)
What's wrong with eugenism? Technology allows eugenism to be implemented without being unfair to anyone. But I fail to see how eugenism is needed to allow monogamous humans to exist on their own terms. I guess mentionning eugenism here is just a 'reductio ad hitlerum'.

Monogamous humans should be able to function in their own societies, with their own laws and a culture adapted to the non-trivial differences in social behavior monogamy entails without having to put up with the predatory behavior of polygamous humans and the cultural propaganda to glorify it. It's been shown that for monogamy as a trait to continue to exist it needs to be the dominant behavior in a group of animals. Others are free to revel in the "joys" of dog-eat-dog polygamous primate societies as long as they engage in this with others who consent.

Also noone exists in a vacuum. One's actions affect others (directly or indirectly) particularly when they live in the same society. Having people with deeply conflicting standards of behavior coexist in a futile attempt at a one-size-fits-all society that inherently favors one group over the other is not going to work.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by philwelch on Monday July 20, 2015 @08:54PM (#9920045)
Cheating is also something that roughly 50-70% of married people do. Sex, along with food, water, and drugs, is one the basic, biological human compulsions and it's part of the human condition, for a large majority of us, to fall victim to it against our better judgment. As wrong as it is to cheat, it's even more wrong (and more harmful, which is perhaps the same thing) to invade people's privacy and expose cheating.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by DanBC on Monday July 20, 2015 @02:24PM (#9917965)
Adultery is illegal in many bits of the US.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by fnordfnordfnord on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:36PM (#9919574)
It is but according to the Wiki it there hasn't been a conviction in the US since 1983.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by chmielewski on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @04:43PM (#9925646)
If you are part of the armed forces under DoD or DHS, you see people being convicted and brought up on adultery charges all the time.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by amyjess on Monday July 20, 2015 @02:02PM (#9917823)
Having an affair actually is illegal in almost half the US, and in some states, it's even a felony.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by balls2you on Monday July 20, 2015 @02:22PM (#9917959)
> Having an affair actually is illegal in almost half the US, and in some states, it's even a felony.

Wow! United Saudi Arabia (USA)!

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by cjsthompson on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:47PM (#9919321)
Saudi Arabia allows polygyny which is the complete opposite of this.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by dragonwriter on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:40PM (#9919588)
Allowing polygyny is not the opposite of criminalizing adultery; its quite orthogonal.

Its the opposite of criminalizing polygyny, which is also common in the US, but that's a different issue.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by cjsthompson on Monday July 20, 2015 @07:38PM (#9919795)
This is certainly what tumblr ideologues who haven't bothered checking scientific facts (behavioral biology) like to believe.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by balls2you on Friday July 24, 2015 @01:41PM (#9943760)
Saudi Arabia criminalizes adultery which is "having an affair". Polygyny means you're legally married which is allowed in Saudi Arabia but having an adulterous relationship is criminal.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by anotherangrydev on Monday July 20, 2015 @11:45AM (#9916779)
Typical.

Free speech! (Until I hear something I don't like!)

Equal rights! (Except for people that are not like me!)

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by jaawn on Monday July 20, 2015 @11:51AM (#9916838)
I don't think this argument really applies. It would be one thing if the site was devoted to assisting "open relationships," but it isn't. It is specifically a service to assist people in "cheating" on their partners (with the assumption being that the partners don't know and wouldn't approve). So, because of this specific detail, I don't think the "people not like me should be treated equally!" argument applies. The betrayal is intrinsic, not a matter of opinion.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by harlanlewis on Monday July 20, 2015 @12:12PM (#9917012)
Judging other people's relationships is a losing game, no matter how objectively you label qualifiers. Few things are more opaque than the unspoken space between other minds, with their unique mix of shared + independent history, context, hopes, doubts, violence, love.

But hey, good luck drawing lines where you choose.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by ArtDev on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:13PM (#9917441)
The sites sole purpose is inherently harmful.

The ads speak for themselves: https://www.google.com/search?q=ashlymadison+ads

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by vectorjohn on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:34PM (#9917619)
This is not a factual statement. It's your opinion. It isn't up to you to decide this for other people.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by jaawn on Monday July 20, 2015 @04:25PM (#9918796)
Its intent is to do something which harms. I don't think the infinitesimal collection of people who want their partners to "cheat" on them justify the flexibility you're implying. Basically, what you are saying, is that some people are not harmed by being cheated on, and therefore it isn't fair for us to judge the actions of the sites users, because maybe all or most of them are in a situation where there is no harm.

I think the simpler explanation (and likely more accurate one) is that in most cases, each AM user has at least one partner which is being harmed by the user's actions and use of the site.

Being accepting and tolerant of different types of relationships and desires is a separate issue. The site was created for, and is marketed towards, people who want to cheat (in the traditional, harmful sense) on their current partners.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by vectorjohn on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:20PM (#9919168)
First, you're putting words in my mouth. All I did was point out that you're just spouting opinions as given facts.

Secondly, still, you continue to make value judgments based on your own personal ethics and assume they're universal truths. Whether there is harm (as you say) truly is debatable. Ending a marriage is breaking your contract, doing something your spouse doesn't like is "harmful". Which ones are ok? Maybe this cheating for many people ends up being a one time thing that the person needed to do to either realize they want to end the marriage or realize they want to change something. Or some other outcome. Regardless, it isn't your or anyone else's job to decide, so please keep your moralizing to yourself.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by jaawn on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:52AM (#9920847)
As I've been trying to explain, the issue is with the secrecy and broken promise/contract because it puts one person's interests ahead of the other. If you disagree with that kind of relationship, that is fine...don't agree to enter into one. If you are in one and you find it is no longer what you want, that is fine too...tell your partner and proceed how you wish.

I am not applying any overly austere morals here. I think you would be hard-pressed to successfully argue that an affair in the traditional sense is not an immoral act. If you promise to be "faithful" to someone, and you break that promise and try to hide it, it is immoral based on most people's morals and understanding.

Sure, you might disagree with popular morals, that's fine. However, a relationship involves two people, and both should be valued equally. If one person thinks it is fine to break their promise and cheat in secret, so they do it despite knowing how the other person feels...they are putting themselves first. They are not treating both they and their partner as equals. That is the issue. It has nothing to do with some sort of ideological anti-affair "beliefs." It is simple respect.

I guess it is even technically "fine" to think you deserve more liberty than others, or that you think others' feelings don't matter as much as your desires (I'm not saying you do, I'm speaking generally). If that is the case, just own up to it and people can choose how to react accordingly. If you find partners that align with your views, great, everyone is on the same page, but if not, people deserve the truth. Everything else is up in the air, but they deserve to know. Keeping it from them is like robbing them of the choice to deal with it or leave.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by reinhardt on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:38PM (#9919278)
Going somewhat off on a tangent here but I'm wondering, what is the factual, tangible harm of cheating that you so take for granted? STDs and unwanted pregnancies, I'll give you that but let's assume that everyone's a responsible adult and wears protection. What else? Trust?

I guess promising to (not) do `X` and not keeping your word makes you untrustworthy but what is the literal harm on someone other than the self-referential belief that breaking promises is bad? To illustrate, let's assume that `X` is something like "I promise to not eat zucchini without you ever again". How is "cheating" by secretly gorging once on zucchini with some friends harmful to the person you give it to, other than their self-induced idea that it is bad?

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by jaawn on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @02:33AM (#9920812)
It is, quite simply, that they feel intense negative emotions and betrayal. It does not really need any more explanation than that. You can tell a distraught "victim" of cheating that they weren't technically harmed, but I don't think that would make many of them feel better.

Basically, it is irrelevant if they "should" or "shouldn't" be harmed, most of them will feel harm once the affair inevitably comes to light. I don't really agree with it, but even if it is irrational to feel harmed over an affair, and even if it is based on self-referential beliefs, people still feel the feelings, and those feelings hurt.

If the cheater knew those feelings would probably happen, and they already promised they would not engage in the behavior, and then they do it anyway...in secret...that is obviously wrong by most people's standards. There are a lot of important "if"s in there. Notice that I did not say that having multiple partners is harmful, or that leaving a partner is wrong, or that it is "always wrong" for someone in a relationship to go off with someone else for awhile. I did not say any of that.

However, when the relationship is a committed relationship, in the most common, Western, traditional sense, it is wrong to have an affair, especially a secret one. If you disagree with that kind of relationship and commitment, that is totally fine, but don't promise that to someone, and if you change your mind be up front about it.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by vectorjohn on Tuesday July 21, 2015 @05:15PM (#9925873)
They only feel intense negative emotions and betrayal if they know about it. So really, giving them that information is the harm.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by fnordfnordfnord on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:31PM (#9917590)
Inherently harmful to whom?

PS Those ads are awful.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by Lawtonfogle on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:07PM (#9917396)
>Free speech! (Until I hear something I don't like!)

What limitations do you think should be put on the exchange of information (words, thoughts, concepts, pictures, videos, executable, etc.). For almost everyone I've ever asked, the answer was never 'none'. They may start there, but soon after I started listing more concrete examples I find one that makes them take back that 'none'.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by dublinben on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:29PM (#9917576)
You didn't ask me, but the correct answer is 'none.'
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by Retra on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:45PM (#9917701)
You realize that you are advocating for single-point-of-failure, right? That if I learn anything at all about you, that I should be free to share it with whomever I like in any way I want, and for any reason?

Do you honestly believe that you are so good at guarding information that you have nothing to fear from it's free propagation? And that this is not only true for you, but for everyone?

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by dublinben on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:58PM (#9917800)
Would censorship legislation prevent you from doing so, if you really wanted to?

We should spend more effort removing the potential harm that unwanted information disclosure can cause, rather than running around plugging leaks and jailing whistleblowers.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by Retra on Monday July 20, 2015 @03:01PM (#9918238)
>Would censorship legislation prevent you from doing so, if you really wanted to?

Would murder legislation prevent you from killing someone if you really wanted to? No? Then I guess there's no point in making murder illegal.

Legislation makes it clear what is sanctioned. It doesn't prevent crime. It defines crime.

>[...] unwanted information disclosure [...]

Legislation is how you say what information disclosure is unwanted. Without it, there is no basis for handling information disclosure at all.

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by eropple on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:44PM (#9917687)
Cool, so it's alright for me to air your dirtiest of laundry? I'll remember that.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by dublinben on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:56PM (#9917784)
Even if I took umbrage to that, how is censorship legislation going to stop you?
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by vectorjohn on Monday July 20, 2015 @05:25PM (#9919207)
It is perfectly legal, yes. You still are an asshole if you do it.
Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by unprepare on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:02PM (#9917352)
Typical.

Free Speech! (has nothing to do with government censorship or banning of speech of any kind)

Equal rights! (has nothing to do with people being granted rights equally by the government, or those rights being applied unevenly)

Is someone here promoting censorship or banning of a type of speech?

Is someone of Class B being persecuted for a crime Class A would not be persecuted for?

If the answer to both questions is no, then we are not discussing free speech or equal rights.

Having a lack of sympathy for someone who committed a crime (in this case a contract violation) is neither anti-free speech nor anti-equal rights.

Do you think it would be better for us to feel more empathy for contract breakers than for those whose marriages have been adversely affected?

Re:Online Cheating Site AshleyMadison Hacked by jasonlotito on Monday July 20, 2015 @01:59PM (#9917805)
Oh, I can play "snarky HN comment" too! Ahem...

Typical.

Privacy! (until people I disagree with have their privacy taken).

The Free Speech/Equal Rights remarks weren't about this case. The GP's comment was alluding to them and comparing them to Privacy, which was what was being discussed. Your remarks about Free Speech and Equal Rights are pointless and immaterial.

> Having a lack of sympathy for someone who committed a crime (in this case a contract violation)

Just curious, what crime did they commit in signing up for AM? What proof do you have that they did sign up? What proof do you have that the released data will be accurate? What contract did they violate by signing up for AM?

I'm curious to know what proof you have besides assumptions to make a bold statement that anyone mentioned in the released data is immediately guilty of something.

> Do you think it would be better for us to feel more empathy for contract breakers than for those whose marriages have been adversely affected?

Do you think it would be better for us to find people guilty until proven innocent, or innocent until proven guilty?