Re:How we store 400M phone numbers with fast lookup
by vidarh on Sunday July 19, 2015 @01:36PM
(#9911997)
I'm sure that works great for 15m. (EDIT: To be clear, I love CDB, and I'm not being sarcastic - for 15m it's probably perfectly fine; it's just space inefficient for large datasets where the combined key+value lengths are very low)
But even if we ignore the hash table pointer tables which can be made arbitrarily small at the cost of probing a higher number of entries on average before finding the right key (but in reality you'd want them to be fairly large), the minimum space used per entry is [1]:
8 bytes for the length of the key and length of the value + 5 bytes for the key + 2 bytes for the value, so 15 bytes per number, or 6GB (EDIT: fixed numbers to account for BCD encoding of number). Which means you'd need to switch to one of the (non-standard) 64-bit CDB-inspired formats, as CDB itself can only handle 4GB data files.
But even if we ignore the hash table pointer tables which can be made arbitrarily small at the cost of probing a higher number of entries on average before finding the right key (but in reality you'd want them to be fairly large), the minimum space used per entry is [1]:
8 bytes for the length of the key and length of the value + 5 bytes for the key + 2 bytes for the value, so 15 bytes per number, or 6GB (EDIT: fixed numbers to account for BCD encoding of number). Which means you'd need to switch to one of the (non-standard) 64-bit CDB-inspired formats, as CDB itself can only handle 4GB data files.
[1] CDB format: http://cr.yp.to/cdb/cdb.txt