News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Let's talk about a hypothetical public-facing service” by nadams on Saturday July 18, 2015 @10:05PM (#9909750)
> just every day you're in danger of losing a drive by a small statistical amount.

Which is why for important data I always use some sort of RAID (or cloud syncing). If I lose a drive I won't lose all my data (presumably though if I bought both drives at the same time there is a chance that both could fail at the same or close to the same time).

> That said, if you're running your ReadyNAS with raid 10 (mirrored drives in a RAID 0 config)

ReadyNAS and other products use a special type of RAID that is actually kind of clever (that will use all space regardless of disk size). I know many would criticize the special RAID but I've had more issues with Linux software RAID than I have had with ReadyNAS (nothing related to data loss). But suffice it to say if 1 drive fails then in theory the data should still be ok (at least that is what their claim to fame is).

My personal opinion - I feel like the ReadyNAS will die before the drives. I'm not saying they couldn't or won't die - but I feel like that would be highly unlikely and even more unlikely for more than 1 to fail at once.

Maybe I'm just paranoid - but when I worked on my last SAN it felt like the company used the cheapest possible drives with a short MTBF for the simple reason that my employer would have to keep using them and keep paying for their warranty service (this wasn't a big name like Dell).

Re:“Let's talk about a hypothetical public-facing service” by Veratyr on Saturday July 18, 2015 @11:38PM (#9909966)
> Which is why for important data I always use some sort of RAID (or cloud syncing). If I lose a drive I won't lose all my data

Just a friendly reminder that RAID != backup. There are numerous data loss cases that RAID does not deal with.

Personally I use striped ZFS with important volumes periodically snapshotted, replicated to external (and encrypted) disks and then stored offsite (cycle through a couple of sets of disks). Most important data is also periodically synced to cloud storage (as well as offsite disk).

This accounts for:

- Single disk failure (striping)

- Bitrot (ZFS scrubbing can reveal bitrot on disk and correct it from parity)

- Human error (snapshots)

- Catastrophic damage to home NAS (offsite backups)

RAID alone (depending on the particular implementation) will generally not deal with the 3 latter failure cases.