Re:MPs win surveillance powers legal challenge
by TheGrimDerp1 on Friday July 17, 2015 @11:05AM
(#9903066)
| There can't ever be absolute rights in this context, because at some level, even the most widely accepted and well-regarded rights that we want to protect will inevitably come into conflict. |
And people wonder why Americans love guns so much...
Re:MPs win surveillance powers legal challenge
by mhurron on Friday July 17, 2015 @12:20PM
(#9903463)
Yes they do. Do you really believe you're going to use your personal arsenal against the Federal Government if it decides to take some other right they agree with?
Guns aside I think the idea of personal sovereignty is an interesting one. It a concept that is almost completely lacking in the UK. We wrongly believe that people bodies and property are policed by social values and politeness. The greatest crime is not attacking someone's rights but breaking a taboo. This is very different to the American concept of individual liberty where people are actually allowed to be rude!
Re:MPs win surveillance powers legal challenge
by zbyte64 on Friday July 17, 2015 @05:01PM
(#9905307)
Guns no, but encryption yes. The right to "arms" includes encryption. Too bad the NRA sucks up the 2nd amendment discussion and casts it as only pertaining to guns.
Hoarding guns makes it easier for some people to sleep at night because they think that the government is going to come for them, or they are preparing for the fall of civilization.
Re:MPs win surveillance powers legal challenge
by TheGrimDerp1 on Friday July 17, 2015 @05:26PM
(#9905433)
not on the internet I don't.
I think the problem with the current politics of fear is that it does seek to promote one absolute right -- the right to be safe from attack by bad people -- as more important than all the others. Of course, it is impossible to truly achieve that goal no matter what you sacrifice. But in the quest to do so, more balanced "greater good" philosophies developed over centuries of human civilisation, like preferring to die on your feet than live on your knees, or preferring to risk letting a guilty man go free rather than risk imprisoning an innocent one, or refusing to negotiate in the face of threats, can be cast aside all too easily. That's what is happening today.