News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just Got Out of Prison. Now What? by ectoplasm on Friday July 17, 2015 @02:41AM (#9901512)
Hey man, I dunno, two other commenters besides me failed to understand your original logic. I just tried to explain what was unclear about it.

> A roughly Pareto law (80/20) applies to criminals.

Okay, criminals can be divided into groups 80 and 20.

> The majority of all murders are done by a small group.

Presumably, since it's the next sentence, the murders are done by group 20.

> Meanwhile, the majority of all murderers never commit another crime.

[^] The majority of group 20 commits only one offense. (Unless of course you state that murderers have a non-murder prior, which was the clarification you refuted.)

> Jail sentences should be relatively light for the 80 and fairly severe for the 20.

[+] The non-murderers in 80 should get light sentences and murderers in 20 should get severe sentences.

> That means first-time offenders should get minimal sentences, but repeat offenders should get long prison terms.

Because of the statement marked [^], the majority of murderers should get minimal sentences, which conflicts with the statement marked [+], unless you state that all murderers have a non-murder prior.

There are no comments on this comment yet.