> Personally I'm all for harsh sentences for violent offenders
Why? There's no clear evidence that particularly harsh sentences actually reduce recidivism.
Re:Just Got Out of Prison. Now What?
by waterlesscloud on Thursday July 16, 2015 @06:27PM
(#9900267)
What it does do is prevent the violent offenders from committing crimes against the citizenry for the duration of the sentence.
Is there any evidence that one violent act means that a person will likely commit more?
I would have a hard time believing that isn't the case, but I'm open to any evidence you have.
Wouldn't the burden of proof be on those asserting that someone who commits one violent crime needs to be put away so they won't commit more?
Nope. You're staking out a position that's counter-intuitive, so you're the one who has to get the data ball rolling.
I don't really care if it reduces recidivism or not. If you commit a violent crime you deserve to be in jail.
The majority of people are incarcerated for non violent offences, if you give lesser sentences to those people and not give them a criminal record it would solve most of your issues.
Yeah, I think violence is a pretty clear dividing line. I'm not particularly interested in trying to eradicate petty crime by putting hookers, pot dealers, and scam artists away for long periods of time. Even if it worked (and it doesn't) it wouldn't be just.
Previous episode of violence is a reasonable predictor of future violent behaviour.
I'm not sure that gun ownership for violent people is a good idea.
On the jobs side I have no idea what the right thing to do is. On one hand if people with criminal records can't get jobs you're pretty much forcing them to return to a life of crime. But on the other hand... if I'm hiring people I'll only hire a guy with a serious criminal record if I can't find anyone else. That's just self preservation.