>> It's main risk right now is that DRAM vendors are more conservative and mass market than most fabs.
recently micron released a memory based processor/state-machine architecture called "automata". This might be a good sign that the problem you mention will be solved.
Re:Intel delays chip-making changes
by nickpsecurity on Thursday July 16, 2015 @11:55PM
(#9901215)
That was a really neat processor. That's what happens when hardware vendors look at FSM problems their way instead of support software developer's way (eg C lang). The best bet might for those using memory fab tech to haggle one of the fabs to do MPW's on, say, one production line. Fab as a whole can keep cranking out tons of memory chips, new players can crank out theirs, and any risk is very limited.
The problem has already been solved outside memory fabs several times over. The memory fabs just need to take some steps, themselves. If I were them, I'd push I.P. vendors to follow path of Micron and Venray just to get more fab customers.
Except you still need a fast bus for the CPUs to talk to each other and to access shared memory. So for all but the most embarrassingly parallel workloads, you just move the bottleneck from the memory bus to the shared cache bus, do you not?
Re:Intel delays chip-making changes
by white-flame on Thursday July 16, 2015 @05:23PM
(#9899954)
A memory bus has long delays to set up a transfer, is typically only 64 bits wide, and only achieves good bandwidth on large burst operations.
The Venray design allows single-cycle random access to full 4096 bit cache lines, at least as described in the earlier iterations. Contention is far less an issue in this model, for many cores on 1 large memory chip. Multi-chip sticks are then akin to multi-socket motherboards.
Re:Intel delays chip-making changes
by nickpsecurity on Thursday July 16, 2015 @11:49PM
(#9901196)
Good answer.
http://www.venraytechnology.com/Making%20a%20Frosted%20Cake%...
I think it was a brilliant reframing of the problem: move CPU's to memory with its cost-benefit analysis rather than vice versa (status quo). The design also achieves what some exascale proposals are trying to achieve with R&D in terms of better integrating CPU & memory with lower energy. It's also massively parallel (128 cores) and optimized for big data. Close to your next big thing.
It's main risk right now is that DRAM vendors are more conservative and mass market than most fabs. There's not all this MOSIS, multi-project runs, and so on. Their low-volume cost is currently high (tens of thousands). They might be facing a chicken-and-egg problem in terms of hitting enough volume to get a nice, production deal. I do like their tech and think it has far more potential than what they're doing right now.