News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel delays chip-making changes by detaro on Thursday July 16, 2015 @12:11PM (#9898086)
for desktop systems, small number of fast cores is still better than multiple slower ones, since a lot of the software that would profit most isn't very well optimized for making use of many cores. IMHO there is not that much demand for better performance in bread-and-butter CPUs anyways, things like embedded graphics, power saving etc matter more.

The top desktop CPUs have 6 or 8 cores, and Intel Xeons go up to 18.

And there are the Intel Xeon-D and Atom Cxxxx, which go in the direction of having (at the moment up to 8) smaller cores and low energy usage, for tightly packed servers and networking devices. I guess once they get more established they might get higher-power counterparts with more cores.

And the Xeon Phi might get there, if Intel manages to do what they promise for future generations.

> each core seems to grow to fit the available space, with only adding a few instructions, which only add marginal utility. Not the same as doubling the number of cores, which would double theoretical performance.

The progress between generations isn't big enough to allow doubling the core count in the same envelope with the same per-core performance. So they only make the cores a bit better & slowly add a few cores (mostly to the high end).

high-end phones actually have quite a few cores in the meantime, but there they are staggered for different usage scenarios: a few slow, efficient cores combined with faster and more energy-hungry ones for high-performance tasks. But for most x86 systems that would "waste" to much of the chip I guess.

> but should CPU designs be hobbled simply because the software industry is not where it should be?

Designing CPUs for "the perfect software" is nice, but not what sells to the vast majority of the market. As listed above, there are quite a few niche lines that go in that direction, even if you just look at only Intels offerings.

Re:Intel delays chip-making changes by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday July 16, 2015 @02:24PM (#9899007)
There's no demand for better performance given current architectures and applications.

It's not hard to imagine more interesting architectures and applications - for example associative language processing, supercomputer-powered robotics, games and UIs that have true cinematic 3D photorealism, or gestural 3D interfaces with very large retina displays.

The problem is really the pace of OS and UI design. We're still using the Xerox Parc GUI model forty years after it was invented, the POSIX OS model some fifty years after it was invented, and the sequential Von Neumann architecture sixty years after it was invented.

These were all breakthroughs at the time, but they should never have become the last word. Research of equivalent creativity seems to have stalled now. IMO it's not just because the low-hanging fruit has been picked, but because there are commercial, academic, and political pressures holding it back.

There may be a game changer generation ten or twenty years from now. But it looks like the pace will be slow until then.