If the movie is made to create a negative emotional response then I suppose one can say it succeeded in doing so, but it still doesn't make it good to the people who view it negatively.
I'm going with the classic definition; good as in "satisfactory in quality, quantity, or degree" or "of high quality; excellent".
I don't think there's anything to agree with in terms of message since I didn't see in it any condoning of Fletcher's behaviour. Sure, in the end his approach did uncover greatness, but through seeing the toll it took on Neiman, I certainly wouldn't say the film advocates that that is how music should be taught. I also wouldn't say it contained a warning either.
There are several possible messages you could read into the movie, and that lends it depth.
You don't have to like movies for them to have been good! You could despise a character while still thinking the movie was good for making you despise the character. That's an art.
If they have a strong emotional impact on you, they've "worked" (other than if they're just crap) because you talk about them, digest them and question their messages. A ton of great movies explore the darker side of humanity by using despicable characters; that's the beauty of story.