News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why “Whiplash” Won an Oscar for Best Editing by estefan on Thursday July 16, 2015 @03:33AM (#9895840)
> I thoroughly despised this movie.

You don't have to like movies for them to have been good! You could despise a character while still thinking the movie was good for making you despise the character. That's an art.

If they have a strong emotional impact on you, they've "worked" (other than if they're just crap) because you talk about them, digest them and question their messages. A ton of great movies explore the darker side of humanity by using despicable characters; that's the beauty of story.

Re:Why “Whiplash” Won an Oscar for Best Editing by talmand on Thursday July 16, 2015 @09:45AM (#9897101)
Just because a movie evokes a strong emotional impact doesn't make it good. A strong emotional response can be highly negative as well.

If the movie is made to create a negative emotional response then I suppose one can say it succeeded in doing so, but it still doesn't make it good to the people who view it negatively.

Re:Why “Whiplash” Won an Oscar for Best Editing by estefan on Thursday July 16, 2015 @11:11PM (#9901119)
Good as in effective at making the audience feel what the screenwriter set out to make the audience feel, but not necessarily good as in enjoyable.
Re:Why “Whiplash” Won an Oscar for Best Editing by talmand on Friday July 17, 2015 @10:24AM (#9902852)
Saying a movie is good and saying the screenwriter is good at their job is two different things.

I'm going with the classic definition; good as in "satisfactory in quality, quantity, or degree" or "of high quality; excellent".

Re:Why “Whiplash” Won an Oscar for Best Editing by hellofunk on Thursday July 16, 2015 @09:38AM (#9897048)
However, most (good) movies do have a lingering message, a thesis point the filmmaker is trying to make about people or the world. What do you think the message was in this movie, and do you agree with it?
Re:Why “Whiplash” Won an Oscar for Best Editing by estefan on Thursday July 16, 2015 @11:20PM (#9901131)
It's a while since I watched it but I guess it's about the length some teachers will go to if they want the legacy of being the teacher of a great musician. It's about a nasty, revengeful, obsessive character who will stop at nothing to separate the wheat from the chaff to uncover a diamond or to screw over his enemies.

I don't think there's anything to agree with in terms of message since I didn't see in it any condoning of Fletcher's behaviour. Sure, in the end his approach did uncover greatness, but through seeing the toll it took on Neiman, I certainly wouldn't say the film advocates that that is how music should be taught. I also wouldn't say it contained a warning either.

There are several possible messages you could read into the movie, and that lends it depth.