I see companies like Uber disrupting the industry by removing inefficiency. Licensing, medallions, appeasing public bureaucrats, etc are inefficiencies. That's not to say that regulation is inherently bad, but we need to let new industries grow and see its challenges first -- instead of applying outdated concepts (like medallions, licensing) to new technology.
For example: USPS, by law, has a monopoly on mail delivery. Just imagine if USPS banned all e-mail providers and forced you to use your @usps.com inbox. Is this a net benefit? Is the taxi industry banning all ridesharing apps and forcing you to use taxis a net benefit?
All of these things have costs. Uber didn't remove the inefficiencies from the system, they just ignored the laws that cause them. I too can remove "inefficiencies" from my bottom line by not paying my taxes, right?
I love Uber. I love that's it's on demand. I love that it's cheaper. But if you recall the time before UberX—when their was only black car service and all drivers had to have Passenger Carrier Permits, commercial insurance, and comply with CPUC rules and regulations—it WASN'T cheaper. The minimum was $15 a ride. SF to Sausalito was $80.
Uber started with a great premium service that was compliant with the law and fixed a real problem. Uber expanded by saying, "We need to grow. Fast. The law no longer applies to us."
Uber enforces the paperwork requirements of each (product type, geofence) permutation. Why would it require something like a Passenger Carrier Permit, if local law does not require it?
If you RTFA, you'll notice that the issue is failure to hand over trip data and GPS logs. Regualators allegedly want them to make sure disabled people and people with service animals are not discriminated against, but I'd be stunned if that's all the data was used for once it fell into government hands.
Uber maintains commercial automobile insurance that covers U.S. partner drivers that operate under the “Ridesharing” or “Transportation Network Company” (“TNC”) model through Uber’s TNC subsidiaries, Rasier LLC and its affiliates.(1)
http://newsroom.uber.com/2015/01/certificates-of-insurance-u...Most of us sees a purpose in paying tax. But, say example, you made an app that files your taxes just like an agent. You could call it TurboTax and sell it, and save $100s of dollars for tax filers. You provide insurance so that if your app does something wrong, you will reimburse people who get penalised.
The point is, the law has always been: if you drive commercially, you need commercial insurance. This is what keeps most people from driving commercially.
Bernie Madoff's investors would disagree.
Licensing primarily works by raising the barrier to entry, discouraging 'bad actors' from signing up because society-wise, 'bad actors' are more distributed among poorer demographics and are unable to afford licensing.
For one, they make no mention of requiring commercial vehicle insurance (https://www.uber.com/driver-jobs) and say that drivers only need personal vehicle insurance.
They have contingent liability injury insurance with a total available of $100K.
They talk of having commercial insurance during trips, but it is only third party liability and UI/UM. If you're a passenger in an Uber accident and insurers decline to cover when they become aware the vehicle was driven commercially, you're out of luck.
Of course, that requires you to commit a crime first, but it's not like the licenses prevent you from doing so.
And even then, The overwhelming majority of cabbies who killed and maimed passengers and pedestrians in the past five years are back behind the wheel. Of 16 fatal or serious crashes since 2009 examined by The Post, only two of the drivers had their licenses revoked, according to a review based on a Freedom of Information Act request.
http://nypost.com/2014/02/09/cabbies-who-kill-or-maim-in-nyc...
Licensing isn't just 'we are not a scam' any more than a "site seal" on a website means anything.
Plenty of companies with valuations in the 8 and 9 digit range have a history of doing dubious things up to and including things that have been known to cost lives.
Licensing doesn't prevent that. But does help with some of the things needed to minimize. Uber just "opted" out of "inefficient regulation".
How much was Bernie Madoff's fund worth when he was arrested?
So Uber has provided significant positive sum gains on top of whatever negative externalities they've thrown off, which makes it much harder to claim that this is a case of merely avoiding regulations others have to follow. Taxi companies could have done all of positive-sum things Uber did [2], but didn't.
So I don't think that narrative fits the situation, or at least, can't account for than 1/3 of Uber's appeal.
[1] specifically, some insurable events that are generally accepted to be the company's responsibility to cover and not the driver's.
[2] easy-to-use app, removing the tipping dance, clean cars, mutual rating, quick action on complaints, reliable follow-up when a ride is requested, pooling rides, cashless transactions, etc
Step 4: Find a sucker to dump the whole company on before the law catches up and walk off into the sunset.
Step 1: Find a regulated industry (taxi, hotel, liquor, etc.)
Step 2: Create an app and label yourself as being part of the "sharing economy" that is disrupting the industry
Step 3: Completely ignore all regulation
Step 4: Profit — largely because you don't have to pay for licensing, insurance, etc. while everyone else in the industry you are trying to disrupt does