Re:Users Rationally Rejecting Security Advice (2009)
by Spooky23 on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @07:01PM
(#9894549)
NAT is generally paired with a firewall.
Tell me how you would ship a device for $20 that will support an arbitrary number of IP devices behind the firewall on virtually any ISP scenario out of the box with zero or minimal installation?
NAT itself doesn't create security, but it brings a standard use case that is easy to secure.
Re:Users Rationally Rejecting Security Advice (2009)
by api on Thursday July 16, 2015 @12:29AM
(#9895489)
NAT is for stretching IPv4. That's it.
As far as security goes, firewalls don't require it. Not only that, but I share the admittedly minority opinion that firewalls are a crutch for bad system security and that we should be working to fix that problem. A system that requires a firewall to be secure is broken.
I've thought the same about highly restrictive network firewalls for years. Most threats today are 'pulled' in via http, e-mail, software update feeds, etc., or entry is made via phishing or social engineering. Highly restrictive firewalls don't do anything about any of that, and they impose significant inconvenience. Your firewall is security theater.
Part of the problem with security is that it's a gut feeling, unsupported "expert" opinion, and tech-folklore driven discipline. At worst it's cargo-cultish and almost superstitious.
For one example consider the extremely common -- and utterly dumb -- belief among many that NAT improves security. It's a superstition. How? What threats does it mitigate that can't be mitigated otherwise? Get concrete, give examples, show data. Nope.