This is deliberate and sneaky - if someone just clicked through the dialog they'd automatically sign up to broadcast to the world what was before set as private communication.
The discussion on that blog mirrors my experience with the tool, I had to reset most of my things to "Only Friends" after going through the tool.
I expect people experiencing this just forgot to click one of the radio buttons or something. It would be better if the wizard defaulted to "old settings" for everything, but it really isn't that hard to use.
I can however state that from my personal experience all of my information was set to "Only Friends" and after selecting "Old Settings" for everything, most of my privileges were reset to "My Networks and Friends" ... I don't have documentation of that, but that was my experience with the tool. I had to manually go back through each to make it map to my desired privacy settings.