If I were a Google competitor -- or a prospective investor -- I'd take this whole attempt to read tea leaves into a narrative with a grain of salt.
> From a Lean (as in Lean Manufacturing) perspective, I see two mistakes: a focus on reducing costs and increasing use of control to do that.
I don't see any real evidence in the article that either of those mistakes are being made, except, with regard to increasing use of control, the reference citing "two people" to vague unspecified increases in approvals for certain kinds of expenses.
> The problem with a cost-oriented perspective is that is too narrow.
Sure, a purely cost-oriented perspective is too narrow. But the information in the article doesn't really support the proposition that that is what is going on at Google.
> Instead the thing to do is to focus on reducing waste or increasing effectiveness, both of which increase value delivered per dollar of expenses.
What little concrete information is given in the article seems to indicate an increased focus on identifying the concrete results that expenses are intended to serve (e.g., the reference to tying hiring to particular plans to achieve concrete goals related to revenue, user-acquisition, etc.) which seems to be a focus on effectiveness, rather than a narrow focus on costs.
Though, really, the article doesn't support a strong conclusion on anything.
Is that really a "trend" we're going to cite to justify this narrative?
Besides, it makes no sense. Even if their revenue growth has stalled out at 20%, their operating costs are only ~35%[1]. You'll very quickly get diminishing returns cutting that, and you still won't be able to maintain anything that keeps investors pleased.
Honestly this seems more like a story written off a press release from this "Bernstein Research".
[1] https://investor.google.com/earnings/2015/Q1_google_earnings...
My great hope is that the new funding rules will make startups accessible to the general investing population. That would, in principle, obviate the desire of existing companies with mature, successful businesses to go out and start unrelated new efforts. Conglomerates aren't very popular these days and haven't been for a long time; it would be nice to see these companies stick to what they're good at, pay their shareholders richly, and then let those shareholders decide whether they want to go invest that income in something else (and if so, in what).
Well, a man can dream, right?
http://www.microsoft.com/Investor/EarningsAndFinancials/Fina...
If the CEO was a Morgan Stanley alum, maybe, having a CFO from that background doesn't seem to be all that strong of a signal of anything.
Could you elaborate why you don't think the CFO is a strong signal?
I don't think the CFO having a history in a large financial firm is strong signal for the same reason I don't think the Chief Counsel having a history in a large legal firm or -- even for a firm that isn't a tech firm -- the CTO having a history in a large tech firm is a strong signal: its a background tightly connected to the specific domain of responsibility.
OTOH, a CEO or COO being drawn from a specific industry other than the one the firm is operating in, or any C-level drawn from an industry both different than that of the firm and not tied to the specific domain for which they are responsible, may be a strong signal.
From a Lean (as in Lean Manufacturing) perspective, I see two mistakes: a focus on reducing costs and increasing use of control to do that.
The problem with a cost-oriented perspective is that is too narrow. For example, suppose you're known for making great hamburgers. If you look at costs, you might say, "Well, beef is our biggest expense, so let's focus on reducing that cost." But the easy ways to do that reduce quantity and/or quality, which also reduce value delivered. Instead the thing to do is to focus on reducing waste or increasing effectiveness, both of which increase value delivered per dollar of expenses.
And the problem with adding control structures as a mechanism is that is slows everything down. You want employees asking, "Am I doing the right thing for the company?" rather than having them pray to the gods of the executive suite every time they need to make a decision.
I think a large part of what made Google so successful is that they approached most problems like engineers rather than MBAs. Looks like there will be opportunities for others to pick up that torch.