News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by akavel on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @09:59AM (#9884909)
Hmmm, personally, I have rather mixed feelings about this. I'd really like to be excited, but so far, I'm not. (And, on a somewhat tangential note, also I'm fairly surprised not to see any voices similar to mine here in the comments; am I the only one? hard to believe; or maybe others like me just shrug and don't bother to write? sounds more probable, to me at least.)

I tried to analyze my thoughts on that; I'll try to give some feedback/impressions, but please forgive if chaotic or otherwise flawed. So, in somewhat random order:

- I'm absolutely not interested in topic of "stock trading", or similar stuff. I'm not into trading/speculation, whether stock, currencies, or else. I don't like gaming others. Or PvP. So, if that's gonna be required, or important, sounds very much like something unfun to me. I like building stuff, and especially useful stuff. In my mind I characterize myself as "an engineer". And from this description, I don't see much in this area for myself. Even if I'm going to be building something here (some in-game "cyberdeck" of tools), I don't know how this could be practically useful for someone else, outside the game; so for now it sounds like wasted time and effort to me.

- From the original announcement, it sounded to me as an attempt at something revolutionary, appealing to a wide audience, and who don't have much free time they can put into this (but I may have overinterpreted, I dunno). Given my previous objection, I don't see how it is so, for now. Specifically, when/if I have free time, I prefer to put it into attempts at some open-source work, so that it would be useful to others, while also I could learn something. But when I don't have much time, I don't see how I could take part in the game in any meaningful way, such that my "score" could reflect my knowledge & abilities. In other words, for now it sounds like it requires some "grinding", and for me that sounds like wasted time (real world requires enough grinding). I don't really see how this differs from MicroCorruption (where I also didn't care to waste time on that), or other "CTF"s. Or, really, "an actual job". Only unpaid^H^H^H^H^H^H"paid" in virtual karma points/pixie dust ("score").

- The one thing that seems mildly interesting to me as of now, is the AVR theme. I'm somewhat hoping to dabble a bit in microcontroller programming (one of my many hobby project ideas). So, if I correctly understood that it's aimed to have a very faithful simulator of an AVR, I may at least learn something in this area, which may be easier than experimenting on real hardware. So, maybe the relatively "wide range of topics" (stock trading, AVRs, compilers, competition) might be the "revolutionary" aspect, so that there's higher chance everyone will find something for oneself? But if I'm willing to grind only on one aspect in-game, then my "total score" will probably be low, no? Unless at least the scores are multi-aspect, not totalled/averaged. Still, if I don't grind on other aspects, they won't show up in my profile, and will remain unknown to "potential employers", no? Also, back to the AVR theme, microcontrollers are closely related to electronics (i.e. very physical hardware: cables, soldering, analog voltages, timing, unexpected capacitances, coupling, etc.), and here I presume I won't be able to learn anything anyway.

All that said, I understand that this is kinda "2nd trailer announcement", and the stuff is not open to public yet, so the jury is still out.

Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by tptacek on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:39AM (#9885192)
We're appealing to a much wider audience than most CTFs, but we certainly aren't trying to appeal to everyone. You don't have to worry if none of this sounds fun to you; that doesn't make anything wrong with you, or us. We're just another thing that exists!
Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by akavel on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @06:00AM (#9928632)
The longer version of your answer (in response to cja's comment below), helped me understand your thoughts on that. Thanks a lot!
Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by dragons on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @09:36AM (#9891151)
for now it sounds like it requires some "grinding", and for me that sounds like wasted time

I haven't seen enough info, either, but I got the same feeling. When I first read about Starfighter I thought "neat, maybe this is a way to avoid the obnoxious typical interview process by demonstrating what I can do with some kind of ranking system." The Starfighter site implies this "Starfighter is not here to fix the job interview. We're here to destroy it, and replace it with something better" http://starfighters.io/

From reading the OP, now it sounds like a way to filter out a few diamonds-in-the-rough in a very specialized area. The system may teach you something, but the people who will shine and rise to the top will (I think) have some natural talent that makes them stand out. What will the vast majority of players get from participating? And how many hours of time do you have to devote to this simulation before you get introduced to a company (if that even happens)?

Well, maybe I'm not the target market because I'd rather spend my free time building my own business than playing a game. I'm currently doing that. But if my business doesn't work out, and I need to go back to work at some point, I don't see this system helping me. I have no idea how much time it would take, and what the possible reward would be. I hope these questions will be answered eventually.

Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by tptacek on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @04:26PM (#9893840)
Since we're counting on lots of people who aren't in the job market to participate, if people get nothing out of Starfighter other than referrals to jobs, we're doing something very wrong.

The first Starfighter CTF is first and foremost a labor of love. I know the hiring angle dominates discussion of the concept, but I can't say this any more clearly: we are sinking all our energy into building the programming game we've wanted to exist for years. The thing we're building is only peripherally connected to hiring.

Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by volkadav on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:22PM (#9886072)
There's a lot of interesting engineering that goes into finance. It's hard to get into the domain where milliseconds are of crucial importance and not involve some seriously hairy engineering. Finance, even aside from the practical engineering aspects, can be full of deliciously crunchy theory and mathematics. It isn't all fifty year old frat boys getting shithammered in tawdry NYC bars (though that part can be fun too when they no longer care what is ordered on the corporate tab ;)). Consider this: google is essentially a gigantic clearinghouse for advertising, a topic I think few here are likely to feel deep personal passion about, and yet how much interesting tech have they cranked out over the course of their corporate existence?

As for reward for effort expended the goal seems to be finding interesting work, and this sounds like a lot more fun than taking time off work to go mumble about the same old things from Cormen while sweating in front of a whiteboard to me, but ymmv. Speaking only for myself, presuming for a second that I have time to mess with this when it is released (no sure thing, full time job and two young kids...), even if I don't get a job out of it, learning something about AVR, security, etc. sounds like a worthwhile return on time invested.

Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by akavel on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @05:57AM (#9928619)
As to the engineering in finance & ads, I fully understand that, but the issue for me is with the topic and goal, or how it's gonna be used. So, this argument doesn't really work for me.

As to the second part, about finding work, that's much more interesting for me as some food for thoughts. Thanks!

Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by aesthetics1 on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @10:55AM (#9885340)
I felt the same way, and I'm happy that I happened upon your post. It just doesn't sound interesting to me. Maybe I had my hopes too high, or maybe my idea over the course of dreaming about this ballooned to be something completely different. Or perhaps I just did not fully understand the concept at the time of that first blog post.
Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by cja on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @11:48AM (#9885799)
I'm a longtime professional developer and Starfighter doesn't appeal to me either. I don't see why I'd spend time on it instead of on paid work or a personal project or open source, all of which would demonstrate my value to an employer and reward me more than playing a game.

I've followed Patrick McKenzie since before BCC and this is the first thing that I don't get. Maybe it'd appeal to me if I played computer games.

Having said all that, I'm not meaning to be negative. Clearly it does appeal to some people. I really only wrote this so akavel would know that he/she wasn't alone! I think uninterested people generally don't comment and it's impossible to be against someone creating a product like this so naturally all the comments are from interested people.

Summary: Nothing against it, it's just not for me.

Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by tptacek on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @12:13PM (#9885993)
Here's our stock answer to this question, which seems to come up a lot:

A lot of very talented people won't want to participate. There are amazing engineers with families whose discretionary coding time is committed entirely to open-source projects. It is not our thesis that we can or should pull those people away from that work.

But those people also have no trouble getting noticed by employers.

Our target candidate is in the workforce but underemployed. They have an aptitude for solving hard, lucrative problems. But they've never had the chance to get their hands dirty, and so nobody will give them that chance. Our target candidate is a .NET line-of-business backend software developer at a boring insurance company who is secretly one of the industry's best distributed systems software debuggers. They shouldn't be wiring yet another database row up to yet another Struts HTML form. They should be optimizing the wire protocol for a RAFT implementation at a software company. Only: nobody knows that yet, not even that candidate.

Those people exist. We think they exist by the thousands. I ran a recruiting project at scale for several years looking for them. We found them, over and over again. It was an incredibly gratifying experience for me, and so: I started a company to do it full time.

You're not one of those people. That's just fine. We're just going to find some great new people for you to work with.

What we can add to that now is:

If you're the kind of person who will mess around with microcontroller assembly for fun, or who will write tooling for random APIs just to see what they can make them do, you might be interested in goofing around with the Starfighter CTF regardless of your professional interests.

We had to pick a couple things to start with, and we think we picked ambitiously: low-level systems programming and high-frequency trading.

Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by kayge on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:25PM (#9888165)
"Our target candidate is a .NET line-of-business backend software developer at a boring insurance company..."

Holy crap, he's talking about me!

"who is secretly one of the industry's best distributed systems software debuggers"

Oh, nevermind.

But I'm still very much looking forward to trying this out! Thank you all in advance for bringing such a cool idea to life.

Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by tptacek on Tuesday July 14, 2015 @05:30PM (#9888202)
How do you know you aren't? Have you tried a bunch of times and discovered that you don't enjoy it? Because I think you missed a sentence in my answer. :)
Re:Starfighter, Summer 2015 by akavel on Wednesday July 22, 2015 @06:05AM (#9928642)
Thanks for writing the comment for me! :) Reassuring to know I'm not alone.