Re:Foods experts won't eat
by karzeem on Thursday December 10, 2009 @02:36PM
(#988359)
I agree that nature doesn't intend anything, but when people say that it does, what they're actually doing is slightly clumsily expressing a very valid concern.
And that concern is that a lot of agricultural science suffers from a dangerous sort of reductionism. We come up with a model for how something grows, and then we assume that anything the model doesn't account for isn't important. (This is actually a general gripe I have about a lot of biological science.)
The fact is that plants and animals evolved to give and take as part of enormously complex systems we've hardly begun to understand. I think it's reasonable not to assume that we can scrap those systems, rebuild them from the top down based on what understanding we do have, and not encounter unforeseen consequences.
And that concern is that a lot of agricultural science suffers from a dangerous sort of reductionism. We come up with a model for how something grows, and then we assume that anything the model doesn't account for isn't important. (This is actually a general gripe I have about a lot of biological science.)
The fact is that plants and animals evolved to give and take as part of enormously complex systems we've hardly begun to understand. I think it's reasonable not to assume that we can scrap those systems, rebuild them from the top down based on what understanding we do have, and not encounter unforeseen consequences.