Re:'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's ...
by baddox on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:45PM
(#9879684)
> What amuses me is that it's generally agreed to be an un-interesting song!
How do you mean? It's not a Bach fugue, but I wouldn't really call it uninteresting. It's a more complex melody than the vast majority of songs you'll hear on the radio.
Re:'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's ...
by jimhefferon on Monday July 13, 2015 @02:13PM
(#9879879)
Keep in mind that it is intended for kids. It is interesting to them.
Re:'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's ...
by baddox on Monday July 13, 2015 @04:00PM
(#9880642)
I don't think the intended audience is relevant. I still don't see what about it is particularly uninteresting. It's all diatonic, sure, but if that's the criterion then a huge amount of music is uninteresting. The melody has a variety of intervals (including an octave), and suspensions on nearly every chord.
Re:'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's ...
by jimhefferon on Thursday July 16, 2015 @05:35PM
(#9900010)
I took the comment to mean that Happy Birthday to You is not interesting compared to, say, Locatelli's Sonata in G Major. The second is simply a more ambitious work, is all.
Re:'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's ...
by dev-da0 on Monday July 13, 2015 @08:51PM
(#9882194)
The issue is the perception of commonness assumes that it's obviously public domain when it's not. Another nail in the coffin of ridiculous IP trolls.
Re:'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's ...
by twerquie on Monday July 13, 2015 @09:44PM
(#9882350)
Agreed, it's actually a rather difficult melody.
Re:'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's ...
by theseatoms on Monday July 13, 2015 @01:03PM
(#9879363)
It's not just science that progresses one death at a time.
I wonder what (and how long) it will take for a new song to unseat it.