Re:Removal of Unsafe in Java 9 – A disaster in the making
by carsongross on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:14PM
(#9879036)
puritanical
I think the correct term is platonic: each of us has an Inner Platonic Engineer who cannot abide the ugliness of real world systems and insist on The Great Rewrite. A lot of progress relies on that engineer.
However, in large, functioning and mature software systems he becomes the enemy.
Re:Removal of Unsafe in Java 9 – A disaster in the making
by taeric on Monday July 13, 2015 @02:20PM
(#9879930)
I question just how much progress relies on that engineer. Be honest here, there are no identified problems that are being solved here. Merely an undesirable in the system that is very effective at its job.
Progress, on other hand, advances something in the way of the problem space. Not merely rearranges something in the solution space.
So, what many of us are seeing here is someone is upset with basically the shape of an API. They have no evidence that I have seen of trouble caused by it. Only a desire that such things not exist. This feels almost puritanical in how it is being exercised. Which is just plain silly for a technical debate.